Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
From Experimental Moment to Legacy Moment:Collaboration and the Crisis of Representation Bob W. White (bio) More than one wave of criticism has attempted to come to terms with the legacy of Writing Culture (Clifford and Marcus 1986), but in many cases these efforts have only reasserted the written word as the locus of anthropological knowledge and the notion of representation as the primary concern for generations of anthropologists to come. In fairness, Writing Culture is neither the culprit nor the cause of this malaise but is symptomatic of a much larger problem in the discipline: anthropology's deep-seated anxiety about relevance (Bunzl 2008). I argue that recent attempts to make sense of the legacy of what Marcus and Fischer referred to as an "experimental moment in the human sciences" (1986), instead of using the benefit of hindsight to help us understand what these debates mean for the discipline or for cultural analysis more broadly, have inadvertently narrowed the possibilities for meaningful discussion about ethnography as a critical practice.1 Recent developments in the field of collaborative ethnography have made significant contributions regarding this question, but there is still a great deal of confusion about how the notion of collaboration was mobilized by the Writing Culture debates. In this commentary I set out to disrupt a self-perpetuating narrative about how a series of critiques in the 1980s (alternately referred to as the "crisis of representation literature" or the "literary turn" or the "Writing Culture debates") changed the rules of the game for the future of the discipline by breaking with a modernist past.2 As a number of commentators have observed, the break with the past signaled by [End Page 65] the crisis of representation literature was not actually very clean (Tyler 1987; Fabian 1990), in part because it did not seek to undermine representation per se but rather to make ethnographic representations more accurate (Said 1989; Nencel and Pels 1991). Furthermore, while Writing Culture did call attention to the political nature of representation, it failed to problematize fundamentally the notion of text, and—more important for the argument here—it was unable to explain how knowledge from ethnographic encounters is produced and put to use. Now, as the contributors to these debates have moved on to other themes and theories, and a generation of scholars influenced by this writing has come of age, it is not clear what the legacy of this moment will be. Legacy Time With the recent publication of the twenty-fifth anniversary edition of Writing Culture (2011), there is a feeling of celebration in the air.3 For many of us who were students of American anthropology in the late 1980s, this critical volume (and the other books often associated with it, especially Clifford's 1988 The Predicament of Culture and Marcus and Fischer's 1986 Anthropology as Cultural Critique) will always be remembered as a "watershed in anthropological thought" (James et al. 1997: 1). The lessons we learned were eye-opening. To see a generation of scholars debating, not about theories or the interpretation of ethnographic data but about the way anthropology subtly reinforces its claims to truth through the use of rhetoric and form, really did feel like a revolution. For those of us who were in graduate school at the time, there was something very liberating about this posture, especially vis-à-vis our professors. And this was the case not only in North America.4 Clearly a light had been shone on the "apparatus" of anthropology.5 This light was blinding but in many ways binding, since the knowledge of the critique required each of us to take stock of what we thought we knew about the relationship between knowledge and power. James Clifford's (1988) critique of ethnographic authority has aged well, not only because it is beautifully written but also because it is true, even today, that anthropologists pull levers behind curtains, much like the Wizard of Oz. And Clifford is not alone. Throughout the texts and the tone of this collection, we were able to see, as Kim Fortun explains, that the "author as hero figure is no longer viable" (2011: xi). The gesture of self-awareness...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bob W. White (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: