Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Investigates that/zero alternation in learner English, suggesting L1 influences optionality patterns.
In recent research, that/zero alternation has become increasingly linked to the emerging focus on optionality. While much attention has been given to its role in different English varieties, there is limited understanding of its patterns in learner English. This study investigates the probabilistic grammar underlying that / zero alternation by comparing Chinese learners of English and English native speakers’ written productions through conditional inference trees, random forests and mixed-effects modelling. The analysis of 2621 complement clauses reveals that while both groups display sensitivity to common complexity-related constraints, divergences emerge across groups as Chinese learners exhibit a marked preference for that in general. Moreover, Chinese learners show a reduced sensitivity to complement clause complexity. Compared to English native speakers, factors such as clause length and the structural complexity of subjects exert a weaker influence on their use of that . Task variables further influence alternation patterns. Time constraints, reference tools and certain essay topics seem to elicit more that in both native speaker and Chinese learner groups. These findings seem to challenge the syntax-oriented probabilistic model by demonstrating how task-specific features reshape constraint hierarchies and how L1-specific processing strategies may affect the relative importance of other constraints. The study advances the classic probabilistic model through its integration of cognitive-task paradigms, offering methodological integration for analysing alternation patterns across groups. Pedagogically, the results emphasise the importance of raising learners’ awareness of probabilistic knowledge. Specifically, they highlight the need to strengthen learners’ explicit marking bias through carefully designed input that gradually increases the complexity of complement clauses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: