Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Critical appraisal evaluates surgical site infection outcomes in laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy, indicating the need for methodological clarity.
Dear Editor, We read with great interest the article by Ezzi[1] evaluating skin staplers versus subcuticular sutures for port-site closure in laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (LSG). The authors deserve recognition for presenting a large registry-based analysis on an important yet underexplored topic. That said, several methodological and perioperative factors need clarification, as they may significantly influence surgical site infection (SSI) outcomes. To begin with, the study does not specify whether fascial (sheath) closure was performed for 10-mm ports. Fascial closure is known to reduce port-site complications, including hernia and deep infections, especially in obese patients. Any variation in this practice could have influenced outcomes between the groups.[2] Another key point is the lack of detail on perioperative antibiotic protocols. The timing and choice of prophylactic antibiotics play a major role in SSI prevention, and even small differences can affect infection rates.[3] The authors mention saline irrigation and instrument change before closure, but standardised wound protection measures, such as antiseptic irrigation or barrier devices, are not described. These measures are known to impact SSI rates and should be addressed.[4] Port-site characteristics, including size, number and location, are also not detailed. Larger ports and increased subcutaneous thickness in bariatric patients are the well-recognised risk factors for wound complications such as seroma and infection.[5] While subcutaneous fat closure was routinely performed, the technique used to eliminate dead space is not standardised. Inadequate closure can lead to seroma or haematoma formation, which may partly explain the higher complication rates observed in the suture group.[6] The study also reports higher post-operative pain scores in the stapler group but does not clarify whether this is related to staple removal or tissue tension. Existing literature shows mixed findings on pain outcomes between staplers and sutures, highlighting the need for consistent pain assessment methods.[7] Finally, the retrospective design introduces the risk of selection bias and unmeasured confounders, including surgeon preference and intra-operative technique. Registry-based studies offer valuable insights, but randomised controlled trials remain the most reliable way to compare the surgical approaches. In summary, this study adds meaningfully to the literature. Still, clarification of key variables, particularly sheath closure practices and antibiotic protocols, is necessary before recommending staplers as the standard method for port-site closure in LSG. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gupta et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: