Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Study evaluated soil quality and maize yield in saline farmland, suggesting compost is more effective than biofertilizer.
In arid and semi-arid regions, severe salinity imposes strong abiotic constraints on farmland restoration. This study evaluated the one-season effects of organic amendments on soil quality, maize productivity, and short-term ecosystem multifunctionality (EMF) responses under severe salinity stress. We conducted a field experiment with biofertilizer (targeting plant–soil biological regulation) and composted manure (targeting direct soil amelioration) applied at different rates. The high-rate composted manure treatment (T6) showed the largest short-term improvements: compared with the chemical-fertilizer-only control under the same irrigation and plastic-mulch management (CK; soil quality index (SQI) = 0.716, yield = 6.657 t ha−1, EMFa = 0.456), SQI increased by 165%, maize yield increased by 41%, and EMFa increased by 104% relative to CK within one growing season. Partial least squares path modeling (PLS-PM) suggested that under biofertilizer treatments, a plant-related association pathway was observed but relatively weak (β = 0.215), whereas under composted manure treatments, EMF variation was mainly associated with soil quality improvement (β = 0.992). Overall, these short-term results suggest that, under the tested application rates and severe salinity stress, high-rate composted manure can more effectively improve baseline soil conditions than biofertilizers during the initial season. These findings offer a preliminary conceptual perspective for a phased management strategy, serving strictly as a preliminary hypothesis where priority is given to soil amelioration in the initial phase and gradual integration of biologically oriented interventions as baseline conditions improve. However, future multi-year and multi-site studies are strictly required to validate the long-term viability of this proposed framework and to test whether these association patterns persist across longer time scales and broader regional contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: