Evidence for Early-Time Spurt-Loss Dominance in Borate-Crosslinked HPG Gel Leakoff for High-Permeability Sandstone

Borate-crosslinked hydroxypropyl guar (HPG) gels are widely used as water-based fracturing fluids in oilfield stimulation. During hydraulic fracturing, their effectiveness depends on the rapid formation of a low-permeability filter cake on fracture walls, which helps reduce fluid invasion, maintain fracture pressure, and support fracture propagation. In high- and ultra-high-permeability reservoirs, however, rapid matrix invasion may occur faster than effective filter-cake formation, causing severe pre-cake spurt loss or even uncontrolled leakoff. Conventional filter-paper tests tend to emphasize stabilized wall-building behavior and may therefore fail to represent the early-time spurt loss in porous reservoir media. In this study, the leakoff behavior of borate-crosslinked HPG fracturing fluids was investigated using a modified static fluid-loss apparatus. Experiments were conducted at differential pressures of 0.5–6.0 MPa through filter paper and artificial sandstone disks with permeabilities from 0.120 to more than 4.0 μm2. The filter-paper tests showed typical wall-building behavior, with limited spurt loss and stable late-time leakoff. In contrast, the sandstone-disk tests revealed a transition from cake-controlled leakoff to early-time spurt-loss-dominated leakoff as permeability and differential pressure increased. When permeability exceeded approximately 1.55–2.42 μm2, spurt loss (Vsp) became the main contributor to total leakoff, whereas the late-time wall-building coefficient (Cw) was much less sensitive to permeability. This indicates that permeability mainly controls the pre-cake invasion stage rather than the stabilized leakoff stage. Based on these results, an empirical spurt-loss model considering permeability and pressure differential was developed, and spurt-loss zoning maps were constructed for engineering evaluation. Limited ultra-high-permeability tests further showed that quartz particles promoted early bridging and reduced leakoff under moderate pressure differentials, but the particle-assisted barrier lost effectiveness under higher pressure differentials. These findings demonstrate that filter-paper-based criteria are insufficient for evaluating HPG gel performance in extreme-permeability formations and that a spurt-loss-based framework is needed for fluid-loss-control design and fracturing-fluid selection in high-permeability reservoirs.