Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Argues Eduard Meyer conceived the ancient city-state before Max Weber, suggesting a complex view of ancient economies.
Summary Contrary to common belief, which attributes the conceptualisation of the ancient city to the works of Jacob Burckhardt and Max Weber, this paper argues that Eduard Meyer had already developed a theoretical conception of the city in antiquity prior to this, characterising it with a term originally borrowed from medievalism: the ‘city-state’. Although Meyer was not the first to use the term ‘city-state’ [“Stadtstaat”], his analysis was the first to develop a full conceptualisation of the origin and development of the polis . Far from the typical misunderstanding of Meyer as a ‘modernist’ who equated the ancient economy with modern capitalism, this paper argues that Meyer had a very complex vision of the ancient economy as a field limited by the political dimensions of the city-state. In this sense, the so-called ‘modernism-primitivism’ debate has been misunderstood by historians: Meyer saw the modernity of ancient societies in the social conflicts generated by socio-economic differentiation, and thus opposed the ‘primitive’ vision of Fustel de Coulanges and others who explained social differences in terms of kinship survival. Meyer’s work would have had a decisive influence on Max Weber, particularly in his gradual abandonment of an evolutionist vision inherited from Theodor Mommsen. Weber’s later characterisation of the ancient city and crucial aspects of his sociological thought, such as his conception of ideal types and his vision of ‘ancient capitalism’, can be traced back to Meyer’s influence. If these developments have remained obscure to this day, it is largely because of the tergiversated version of Moses Finley’s history of historiography that has been uncritically adopted by historians.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marcelo Perelman Fajardo (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: