Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Book examines judgment's implications in various realms through Shakespearean theater, suggesting ethical significance.
Judgment since he has identified and illuminated a topic-judgmentthat is little studied and is taken for granted in Shakespeare Studies.This is his second treatment, Curran having edited an earlier collection of interesting essays on the topic-Shakespeare and Judgment (Edinburgh University Press, 2017)-but I am glad that he has given us his own book-length treatment of judgment as it informs and is informed by feeling (Chapter 1), objects (Chapter 2), vision (Chapter 3), making (Chapter 4), facing (Chapter 5), and community (Chapter 6), his six keywords.It is a brilliant, informed, and historically and philosophically knowledgeable argument that Shakespearean theater stages and enacts "the ethical and social importance of judgment" (1).Curran is careful to note the difficulty of defining judgment, the way we come to know, but one of the genuine contributions of the book is to see that it takes place both within the person and without:Judgment […] is something out there-in the law courts, in the universities, on the tip of God's tongue, and in the codes of socialization.But it is also something in here.Judgment is the psychological faculty possessed by each person, even if its effectiveness may vary depending on circumstance and other factors.At once a faculty, a practice, a method, and a skill, judgment transforms as it migrates across the realms of psychology, rhetoric, politics, science, aesthetics, law, religion, and philosophy.(5)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Scott Crider (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: