Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Speculative history reveals that pirate models influenced governance in Madagascar's Betsimisaraka Confederation, suggesting complexities beyond mere adoption.
According to this interesting and admittedly speculative history, the Betsimisaraka Confederation — an alliance of Malagasy clans headed by a war chief named Ratsimilaho — “fus[ed] together political models and principles derived from the pirates . . . with the existing political traditions of the coast” of Madagascar in the eighteenth century. The factual basis for this speculation is that some Golden Age pirates settled on the coast of Madagascar, conducted business there, took Malagasy wives (Ratsimilaho himself was the son of a European pirate father and a Malagasy mother), and otherwise became deeply embedded in local life. It thus seems plausible that Ratsimilaho and his comrades may have been familiar with institutions of pirate governance.Yet, if we follow the author and conclude that Ratsimilaho and his comrades had those institutions in mind when they formed the Betsimisaraka Confederation, what stands out is not how much of pirate governance they seem to have adopted but rather how much of it they seem to have rejected. For example: Whereas pirate crews popularly elected and deposed their war chiefs (captains) at will, according to Graeber the Confederation's war chief was permanent and hereditary.Whereas pirate crews instituted laws concerned largely with protecting the crew's members against one another, Graeber says nothing about Confederation-made laws concerned with protecting the Confederation's clans against one another.Whereas pirate crews elected officers (quartermasters) to enforce their rules, Graeber refers to no Confederation rule-enforcing officer at all. (Perhaps this authority fell to Ratsimilaho? But if so, the Confederation combined war-chief and rule-enforcement powers in one office, whereas pirates divided them.)Whereas pirate crews made important collective decisions by majority vote, according to Graeber the Confederation made such decisions by consensus.The only commonalities that Pirate Enlightenment identifies between pirate governance and that of the Betsimisaraka Confederation are participatory decision-making and the use of oath rituals. Suffice it to say, roughly the same governance overlap may be found between pirate crews and, for instance, the Iga ikki in Sengoku-era Japan.As for the Betsimisaraka Confederation's participatory governance, it can be accounted for without speculation about borrowing from pirates. Voluntarily formed military alliances between politically autonomous groups, like the alliance between the clans that formed the Confederation, often give such groups voice in alliance decisions for the simple reason that a group is unlikely to join or remain in a voluntary military alliance in which it has no say. If the Confederation's participatory governance was indeed informed by pirate governance, I therefore suspect that the information was superfluous: Ratsimilaho and his comrades would have gotten there just the same in ignorance of pirate governance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peter T. Leeson (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: