Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reveals extreme low lake levels in the Lake Michigan-Huron basin, indicating historical climate conditions.
Extreme lake levels across the Great Lakes basin have significantly impacted society, with record low and highstands during the historical record known back to 1860C.E. Geologists have extended water level history further back in time using strandline landforms and sedimentary records with drowned forests and trees being the most reliable evidence for lower water levels. We describe an in-situ 17th century white pine tree stump submerged in Georgian Bay adjacent to Winkler Island that is 0.53 m below the 175.57 m International Great Lakes Datum (IGLD) 1985 historical record low-water level of Lake Huron. Considering water depth during sampling, glacioisostatic adjustment of the lake bed, and a ∼0.5 m freeboard, the stump records a >40-year lowstand between ∼1650 and 1690 about 2 m below the historical record low lake level. Additional stumps and standing dead trees ∼0.5 m above and below lake level record tree colonization during the most recent historical lowstand that started in 1998. The number of rings present in these recent stumps suggests that the young trees colonized exposed land in a matter of years before they were submerged during the rapid rise in lake level between 2014 and 2016. The 17th century lowstand is unprecedented in magnitude and duration (>40 years) relative to the historical record, which may reflect a drier, cooler and perhaps windier climate during the Little Ice Age (∼1300–1850C.E.).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fisher et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: