Key result
Farm-level biosecurity measures lack consistent evidence for reducing FMD risk in field settings.
Why the study?
Biosecurity measures interrupting foot-and-mouth disease virus transmission are critical during outbreaks, but quantitative data supporting the effectiveness of many recommended farm-level measures are limited.
Do farm-level biosecurity measures mitigate Foot-and-Mouth Disease risk in domestic livestock?
Systematic Review (n=22)
Do farm-level biosecurity measures mitigate Foot-and-Mouth Disease risk in domestic livestock?
There is currently inconsistent and limited evidence to support the effectiveness of specific farm-level biosecurity measures against foot-and-mouth disease in field settings.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Sparse inconsistent field evidence precludes firm FMD biosecurity recommendations; leaves open need for quantitative effectiveness studies.
Introduction Foot-and-Mouth Disease (FMD) is a global threat to cloven-hooved livestock and wildlife species. The causative agent, Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus (FMDV) can be transmitted via aerosols, droplets, and fomites including humans. This makes the need for biosecurity measures that interrupt FMDV transmission during an outbreak critical. However, quantitative data supporting the effectiveness of many recommended biosecurity measures is limited. The purpose of this scoping review was to identify peer-reviewed literature that described or evaluated biosecurity practices to mitigate FMD risk at the farm level in order to inform planning and preparedness efforts in the United States. Methods A systematic search of four databases identified 3,153 unique records. Included reports had to be original, peer-reviewed research, published in English, include information about a biosecurity measure applied at the farm level to mitigate FMD risk, and address at least one major domestic livestock species in the United States (cattle, sheep, goat, swine, American bison). Reports describing results generated entirely in-silico or with surrogate viruses were not included. Results 22 reports were included in this review describing data from 16 (one unreported) unique countries published between 1998 and 2024. Two reports describing experimental studies evaluated handwashing, showering, and changing outerwear, which were found to have variable efficacy. The use of biosecurity measures applied to livestock and their products, personnel and visitors, vehicles and fomites, and disinfection were identified from 20 field reports and observational studies. No biosecurity measures that appeared in more than one report were identified as being consistently effective at mitigating disease risk in a field setting. Discussion The inconsistent and limited evidence to support the effectiveness of specific biosecurity measures in field settings identified through this review makes meta-analysis infeasible at this time and hampers the ability of animal health officials and animal caretakers to plan for and respond appropriately during an FMD outbreak. Improved reporting of biosecurity measure implementation would improve our ability to assess their effectiveness and develop evidence-based biosecurity recommendations for FMD preparedness and response plans.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Smith et al. (2026) conducted a systematic review in Foot-and-Mouth Disease (n=22). Farm-level biosecurity measures vs. No biosecurity or standard practice was evaluated on Effectiveness of biosecurity measures at mitigating FMD risk. Farm-level biosecurity measures lacked consistent quantitative evidence of effectiveness against foot-and-mouth disease in field settings across the reviewed literature.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: