Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper begins from the experience of some practical theologians at the Congregational Studies Symposium in February 2025. The concern aired by those practical theologians was that talk about God’s action and agency within the interdisciplinary space often felt, in practice, unwelcome; they felt ‘bracketed out’. The approach often advocated in response to such issues is to construct an epistemological space where theological conversations can be included. In contrast to such an approach, this paper calls practical theologians to take a riskier, yet potentially more rewarding approach, of engaging in real, human conversations. It argues that more generative and enriching forms of interdisciplinary engagement can come by engaging first as human beings, listening to one another’s interests, passions, questions, and knowledge, while still holding one’s convictions, commitments, and beliefs. The paper begins by critiquing approaches to constructing epistemological space for engagement between social sciences and theology, before picking up Joel Robbins’ vision for interdisciplinary work. Drawing from examples of conversations across difference, the paper proposes that practical theologians enter the interdisciplinary space of Congregational Studies as human beings with postures of ‘holy curiosity’ and ‘bold humility’, thereby opening up the possibilities for new and transformative engagement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
James Butler (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: