Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Parental mentalization is parents’ capacity to understand and interpret their child’s behaviors in terms of underlying mental states. It has been shown to be an important predictor of children’s socioemotional development. Different constructs of parental mentalization have been developed and investigated in distinct research lines. These include reflective functioning, mind-mindedness, insightfulness and parental embodied mentalizing. While all constructs are subsumed under the umbrella term parental mentalization, empirical relations between them are unclear. The present meta -analysis examines the relations between the constructs of parental mentalization, guided by the overarching question on how to conceptualize the umbrella term parental mentalization. We introduce two perspectives: First, a view assuming that a uniform underlying construct, a common capacity, of “parental mentalization” accounts for the different measures; Second, a view according to which parental mentalization consists of multiple dimensions that form a network of overlapping characteristics, interpreted through Wittgenstein’s notion of family resemblance. Furthermore, contributing to theoretical debates in the field, the analyses systematically compared three features of parental mentalizing: 1) Representational and interactional mentalizing, 2) self-reported and representational/interactional mentalizing, and 3) verbal and non-verbal mentalizing. Overall, 55 studies investigating the relations between constructs of parental mentalization were systematically reviewed. Meta-analyses were implemented for relations with at least 3 studies. Results showed significant, albeit modest relations between representational and interactional mentalizing, while results for self-reported and representational mentalizing as well as verbal and non-verbal mentalizing were mixed. These results are more consistent with the conceptualization of parental mentalization as multidimensional. Constructs of parental mentalization show complex and diverse empirical relations that reflect their conceptual overlap.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Steinmassl et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: