Key result
During a 6-month period, 58 usable CIEDs were publicly listed for unregulated sale online in the US, with 81% verified as lost, stolen, or previously sold to a health system.
Why the study?
Recent publications raised concern that promoting humanitarian CIED reuse may foster an unregulated CIED black market.
Observational (n=58)
A small public online market exists for unregulated, often illicitly procured CIEDs in the US, though active monitoring by manufacturers appears to suppress new listings.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Alerts clinicians to possible unregulated CIED sources; supports regulatory monitoring and further safety studies.
BackgroundAn estimated 1 million patients require cardiac implantable electronic devices (CIEDs) but go without annually. This disparity exists in low-to-middle-income nations largely owing to the cost of CIED hardware. Humanitarian reuse of CIEDs has been shown to be safe and feasible. However, recent publications have raised concern that promotion of CIED reuse may foster a CIED “black market,” to the dismay of manufacturers, regulators, and clinicians alike.ObjectiveTo determine if unregulated CIED sales for potential human use is a real issue by investigating unregulated public online CIED sale listings in the United States of America.MethodsAn observational study was undertaken over 6 months using multiple internet search engines from May 1 to November 1, 2019. We cataloged usable CIEDs (still in packaging, manufactured <7 years) and pricing. Manufacturers were contacted to determine status of sellers and unregulated CIEDs using model/serial numbers.ResultsIn total, 58 CIEDs—47 implantable cardioverter-defibrillators and 11 permanent pacemakers—from 4 manufacturers were listed for sale on 3 websites. During the study period, 8 of 11 pacemakers and 37 of 47 implantable cardioverter-defibrillators were sold (price range: $100–$1500 [US dollars]). No new listings were seen in the last 3 months of observation, possibly owing to concomitant industry investigation.ConclusionThere does exist a public online market for unregulated CIED sales in the United States. This specific market seems to be small and unlikely to significantly expand with active monitoring by manufacturers and regulators. An estimated 1 million patients require cardiac implantable electronic devices (CIEDs) but go without annually. This disparity exists in low-to-middle-income nations largely owing to the cost of CIED hardware. Humanitarian reuse of CIEDs has been shown to be safe and feasible. However, recent publications have raised concern that promotion of CIED reuse may foster a CIED “black market,” to the dismay of manufacturers, regulators, and clinicians alike. To determine if unregulated CIED sales for potential human use is a real issue by investigating unregulated public online CIED sale listings in the United States of America. An observational study was undertaken over 6 months using multiple internet search engines from May 1 to November 1, 2019. We cataloged usable CIEDs (still in packaging, manufactured <7 years) and pricing. Manufacturers were contacted to determine status of sellers and unregulated CIEDs using model/serial numbers. In total, 58 CIEDs—47 implantable cardioverter-defibrillators and 11 permanent pacemakers—from 4 manufacturers were listed for sale on 3 websites. During the study period, 8 of 11 pacemakers and 37 of 47 implantable cardioverter-defibrillators were sold (price range: $100–$1500 [US dollars]). No new listings were seen in the last 3 months of observation, possibly owing to concomitant industry investigation. There does exist a public online market for unregulated CIED sales in the United States. This specific market seems to be small and unlikely to significantly expand with active monitoring by manufacturers and regulators.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Akinyele et al. (2020) conducted an observational in Unregulated online sales of cardiac implantable electronic devices (n=58). Unregulated online CIED sales was evaluated on Number of usable CIEDs listed for sale and their registry status. During a 6-month period, 58 usable CIEDs were publicly listed for unregulated sale online in the US, with 81% verified as lost, stolen, or previously sold to a health system.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: