Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Carbon pricing is widely regarded as a central instrument for decarbonizing resource-based industries. In practice, however, carbon taxes are often accompanied by compensation schemes intended to safeguard economic viability. This study examines how the interaction between carbon taxation and compensation design shapes environmental, economic, and distributional outcomes in the Norwegian fishing fleet. Using data for 2020–2023, we analyze emissions intensity, profitability indicators, and compensation allocation across heterogeneous fleet segments under alternative policy scenarios. Using counterfactual policy simulations, we find that structural heterogeneity across fleet segments accounts for most of the modeled variation in both emissions intensity and profitability outcomes. Higher fuel costs generate directionally consistent reductions in simulated emissions intensity, but these effects remain modest and statistically weak relative to persistent technological and operational differences across fleet segments. The simulation results further indicate that compensation mechanisms attenuate the effective carbon price faced by fuel-intensive vessels, with stronger effects on operating margins than on capital returns. The combined tax–compensation regime is consistent with limited institutional alignment. Transfers are largely volume-based and do not systematically reward higher value efficiency per unit of emissions. The findings show that carbon taxation and compensation schemes should not be evaluated independently. Their interaction shapes the simulated translation of price signals into environmental performance, economic exposure, and distributional outcomes. The study contributes to the literature on environmental policy instrument mixes by showing how compensation design can weaken the steering capacity of carbon pricing when transfers offset rather than reinforce environmental incentives.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bertheussen et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: