Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical intervention explores historicity's engagement with culture in Melanesia, suggesting new temporal frameworks.
As an introduction to the special issue Entangled Temporalities: Regimes of Historicity in Melanesia and Beyond this article revisits the concept of historicity by outlining its idea-historical development and critically considering its usefulness for understanding how people engage with the past, present and future in different cultural settings. To push the concept’s analytical purchase further we draw on Melanesian ethnography and François Hartog’s concept of regimes of historicity, showing that temporal orientations tend to be entangled with older and newer temporal orders intersecting in contexts shaped by colonialism, Christianity, globalization and enduring cosmologies and continuing relationships with ancestors. The varying entanglements of these often conflicting temporalities highlight the ways in which people navigate change and act historically. We suggest that to constructively engage with that complexity, we need to attune the notion of historicity more carefully to culturally specific temporal forms such as reciprocal, reversive, ancestral and mortuary time, as well as local forms of more widespread temporalities such as utopian, prophetic, colonial and traditional time. This will afford and enrich grounded comparative work across cultures and historical periods. Overall, the Melanesian cases illuminate how temporal regimes carry political implications, especially when people draw on them during periods of uncertainty to make sense of current events, pasts and possible futures.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Otto et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: