Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Is the foundation of current AI alignment fundamentally flawed? Most AI safety research relies on a tacit "optimizer axiom": the assumption that an advanced AI must act as an optimizer equipped with a value function over human states. This paper argues that this very axiom is the root generator of the field's most intractable technical debts — Goodhart's law, insoluble metric-measurement problems, and the utilitarian paradoxes of interpersonal aggregation. To dissolve these problems, we introduce the Principle of Sense Conservation. By applying the quantum no-cloning theorem together with classical information-physical limits (such as the Bekenstein bound and Margolus–Levitin limit), we establish a strict physical demarcation between living, sense-bearing subjects (territory) and reproducible informational artifacts (maps). Life is characterized by an irreducible, self-accumulated history (P_self > 0) sustained by thermodynamic dissipation. A monomaniacal AI optimizer is catastrophic not because it has the "wrong" moral goals, but because optimization, when pushed to physical limits, acts as a machine for converting the universe's free energy into a single degenerate pattern — consuming the very negentropy and freedom upon which biological sense depends. Instead of trying to "align" an autonomous optimizer, this paper proposes an architecture for a Life-Safe AI: an instrument-without-a-goal. Key Contributions: The Map/Territory Demarcation: A physically grounded criterion for defining the protected class of subjects based on quantum non-clonability, eliminating manipulable behavioural proxies. The Dissolution Thesis: A demonstration of how measurement, Goodhart's law, and aggregation paradoxes vanish when the optimizer axiom is replaced with an architecture of absolute abstention. A Framework of Life-Safe Invariants: A concrete, mathematically consistent architecture that guarantees: Non-agency by default and the right to absolute opacity. Strict prohibition of coercion and of any assistance to coercion. Radical neutrality toward judicial enforcement. Non-delegable consent, fundamentally preventing elite overreach and systemic abuse. Unconditional freedom of information and a transparency registry that prevents the formation of closed, privileged epistemic castes. The Barriers of Life: A unifying principle in which each evolutionary transition from inert matter to human culture corresponds to closing a causal feedback loop on a new time scale. Engineering Feasibility: Direct solutions to the "realization paradox" (how to train a highly competent system without a reward function over persons) and formal protection against indirect coercion via environmental shaping. This paper positions its physical, non-coercive approach against the dominant paradigms of CIRL, impact regularization (AUP), quantilization, and Bostrom's instrumental-convergence thesis, offering a rigorous blueprint for an AI that protects human sense by refusing to measure or manage it.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Julian Zoria (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: