Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Compares model outcomes of energy efficiency policies in Norwegian residential sector, suggesting complementary use of models.
When considering the introduction of energy and climate policies, numerical model analyses are useful tools. Bottom-up energy-system models and top-down general equilibrium models originate from different research communities: energy technologists and energy economists, respectively. We align a version of each type, introduce similar energy policies and compare the outcomes. The case is an energy-saving target for the Norwegian residential sector. We identify some important differences in the scope, data, and assumptions in the two model types that lead to noticeably diverging results. Some general conclusions can be drawn from our case study. The perspective and purpose of the study are crucial when choosing model(s). If the outcome for the consumers is in focus, bottom-up energy-system models give more accurate results about technology choices. They also include one type of response to energy policy that is not present in traditional top-down models: change in the use of non-purchased energy, for instance self-collected wood or ambient energy for heat pumps. On the other hand, top-down models feature a wider range of substitution possibilities in demand, by allowing for changes in demand for energy as well as for other goods, not only in the household sector but in all sectors of the economy. It follows that top-down models are more appropriate when the focus is on economy-wide repercussions that can potentially counteract the impacts on the residential sector. As the two model types have complementary contributions to energy policy planning, they should, ideally, be used together to capture a broad set of policy impacts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bye et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: