Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reveals regime boundaries in finite phase transitions, suggesting a shift from universality classes.
Central proposition: Traditional universality is a mathematical convergence artifact of the thermodynamic limit (L→∞). In real, finite systems, regime boundaries are more fundamental physical quantities than universality classes. Using the Factor Hierarchy Law and the Testability Norms (six functional dimensions × six-tool cross-validation), we performed a systematic cross-model analysis on five phase-transition models (2D Ising exact solution, 3D Ising, 2D Potts q=3, 2D Potts q=4, and 2D XY). Five core discoveries are reported: (1) Bimodal splitting. In a finite lattice, a second-order phase transition splits into two successive regime switches—locking of the ground state (M_sp dimension) and a structural change of fluctuations (U₄ dimension)—separated by an independent transition regime. On 3D Ising L=64, M_sp breaks at T≈4.40–4.50 (Chow F=939.9–1524.1, depending on scan parameters) and U₄ breaks at T≈4.50–4.55 (F=299.1–2335). The same structure is reproduced on 2D Potts q=4 for L=16, 32, and 64. Blind Bai-Perron double-breakpoint detection, independent of the Chow-scan parameter, confirms the bimodal-splitting structure directly from the M–h coefficient series. (2) Precursor regime boundary. The breakpoint of the M_sp dimension across L=16–128 exhibits a mean of 4.50 and a standard deviation of only 0.071—almost immobile despite a 512-fold increase in volume. Potts q=4 (L=16–128) independently reproduces this stability. In contrast, the KT transition (XY model) displays a strictly monotonic convergence (p=0.0000). The available data (L≤128) are not yet sufficient to statistically distinguish "slow convergence" from "structural non-convergence", but the sharp contrast in size-sensitivity between the two transition types constitutes a robust empirical regularity. (3) Tool-dependence theorem. On the exact 2D Ising solution (Tc=2.269185), the Chow test (T=2.2735) and the susceptibility-peak method (T=2.2675) give "critical temperatures" lying on opposite sides of the true value, differing by 0.006. On 3D Ising L=64, five methods applied across multiple observables yield a Tc range spanning 0.325 temperature units. No "critical temperature" exists independently of the detection tool. (4) χ-blindness. On the exact 2D Ising solution, χ yields a Chow F of only 16.8, whereas 1/χ reaches ~10²¹; on 3D Ising L=64, the activation factor is 40. The root cause is a mathematical mismatch between the even-function structure of χ and the odd-function requirement of the Chow test—fifty years of locating Tc via the χ peak have systematically missed the "regime-switch" dimension of phase transitions. (5) Random-bond Griffiths-phase verification. Traditional universality theory predicts that pure and disordered models are equivalent in the long-wavelength limit. The Factor Hierarchy Law, however, predicts that disorder will generate additional regime boundaries. On a 10% disordered 3D Ising model, Bai-Perron detects a new breakpoint at T≈4.25 that is absent in the pure model (significant on both L=16 and L=32, with a BIC improvement up to +42.77). CUSUM and MOSUM are uniformly significant (permutation test p=0.0000). This result constitutes decisive evidence for a paradigm shift—where traditional theory makes an incorrect prediction, the Factor Hierarchy Law makes the correct one. Based on the above, we establish an MRSD tripartite classification framework: first-order transitions display mixed-type switching (intercept jump and slope change of comparable magnitude) in finite systems, second-order transitions display rule-resetting + bimodal splitting, and KT transitions display single-stage continuous crossover. A modified finite-size scaling ansatz is proposed: B(L) = Tc(∞) ± ΔT₀·Φ(L), where Φ(L) ≈ constant for certain regime boundaries over an intermediate range of scales. Overall conclusion: Universality is a convergence product of the thermodynamic limit. In real finite systems, regime boundaries are more fundamental than universality classes. This paradigm shift, from "universality" to "regime boundaries", constitutes a "reduction of universality" within the traditional theory of phase transitions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tang (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: