Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Retrospective study compares clinical outcomes in duration to union and infection rates for two treatments in open tibia fractures, indicating a favorable outcome for supracutaneous plating.
Background: External fixation followed by nailing (conversion nailing) is a common treatment strategy for open fracture treatment. The use of externalized locking plate (supracutaneous plate) to treat open fractures has also been described. This study evaluates the clinical outcomes in duration to union, infection rate and re-surgery rate between supracutaneous plate and conversion nailing. Materials and Methods: This was a retrospective study. We evaluated open meta-diaphyseal (extra-articular fracture, either proximal, shaft, distal or segmental) tibia Gustilo Grade I, II and IIIA treated with conversion nail and supracutaneous locking plate ( SCP ) . Duration to union from the time of injury, infection rate and re-surgery rate were evaluated at a minimum of one year. Results: We reviewed 182 patients, with 83 patients undergoing conversion nail and 99 patients having SCP. Patients with grade I, II and IIIA were 42, 76 and 64, respectively. The supracutaneous group showed a significance shorter duration to union (mean: 33.99 wk ± 23.62) compared with the conversion nailing group (mean: 47.83 wk ± 49.99). Overall, Gustilo II and IIIa grades have a significant shorter duration in achieving fracture union ( P < 0.05) in the group treated with SCP. χ 2 analysis showed that SCP group has shorter union in less than six months in grades I and II and a lesser infection rate in grade IIIa ( P = 0.047). The re-surgery rate in grades I ( P = 0.005) and II ( P = 0.013) was lower in the supracutaneous group. Conclusions: Supracutaneous plating demonstrates good clinical outcome in terms of duration to union, infection and re-surgery rate in treating open meta-diaphyseal tibia fracture.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fuad et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: