Optical coherence: A convenient fiction

We conjecture that optical coherences, i.e., quantum-mechanical coherences between states separated by Bohr frequencies in the optical regime, do not exist in optics experiments. We claim the exact vanishing of optical field amplitudes and atomic dipole expectation values, and we discuss the seemingly contradictory success of assigning finite values to such quantities in theoretical calculations. We show that our conjecture is not at variance with the observed interference between different light sources. The connection to the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking and the identification of entangled states as pointer basis states is discussed.