The Böhme abrasion test (EN 14157) is widely used to evaluate the wear resistance of natural stones; however, the abrasive powder specified by TS 699 requiring 70–80 wt.% crystalline Al2O3 is not commercially available in the Turkish market. Commercially supplied abrasives deviate substantially from both the prescribed chemical composition and the grain-size distribution of TS 699, introducing a recognized but unresolved source of variability in Böhme abrasion measurements. This study evaluates the influence of abrasive type and particle-size distribution on Böhme abrasion performance with the aim of identifying which available abrasive material yields the most reliable and reproducible test results. The emphasis is therefore metrological—on test repeatability and standardization—rather than on ranking the abrasion resistance of the stones. Six natural stones representing contrasting lithologies—four crystalline marbles, one limestone, and one granite—were tested using five abrasive powders: two locally produced natural emery abrasives (Emery-1 and Emery-2), silicon carbide (SiC), white corundum, and brown corundum. Each abrasive was evaluated under both standardized graded conditions prepared in accordance with TS 699 and heterogeneous ungraded conditions reflecting common industrial practice. Chemical analyses confirmed that both emery abrasives deviate markedly from TS 699 specifications, with Al2O3 contents (~57.7 wt.%) well below the required range and Fe2O3 (~24 wt.%) considerably exceeding the standard limit. Sieve analyses further revealed substantial particle-size deviations in several commercial abrasives. One-way ANOVA demonstrated that abrasive type exerts a statistically significant influence on abrasion performance (F = 8.99, p < 0.05, η2 = 0.297). SiC consistently produced the highest abrasion values, followed by corundum-based abrasives, while emery abrasives showed comparatively lower but stable performance. Independent-samples t-tests showed that particle-size grading significantly affected abrasion performance only for brown corundum (p < 0.05), attributable to its markedly elevated coarse particle fraction. Petrographic analysis, XRD, and SEM–EDS characterization of the investigated rocks confirmed that abrasion response is additionally modulated by rock mineralogy and microstructure. Under standardized grading conditions, SiC provided the most consistent and reproducible results across all lithologies, supporting its suitability as the reference abrasive for inter-laboratory Böhme testing. Locally produced emery abrasives, despite their chemical non-compliance with TS 699, yielded stable and reproducible outcomes under controlled grading, supporting their potential as cost-effective alternatives for routine testing.
Metin Bağcı (Thu,) studied this question.