Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Investigates verdict influences of defendant race and jury composition, suggesting leniency shifts occur regardless of race.
OBJECTIVE: We tested the roles of defendant race (White/Black/Indigenous) and jury racial composition (all-White/racially heterogeneous) on individual verdicts, group verdicts, and verdict change in a simulated criminal trial. HYPOTHESES: We predicted that individual verdicts might demonstrate similarity-leniency among White jurors, with a reduction for those assigned to racially heterogeneous juries. For group verdicts, we expected that all-White juries might demonstrate bias toward racialized defendants. We predicted that participants in racially heterogeneous juries would be more likely to change their verdicts postdeliberation. METHOD: = 174) were assigned to racially heterogeneous juries. Participants watched a trial video, provided individual verdicts, and then deliberated in groups for up to 60 min before reporting a final verdict or a hung jury. RESULTS: = .46, 95% CI [.21, .98], defendants, before deliberation. A dramatic leniency shift (5.8% of juries, compared to 26.0% of predeliberation jurors, convicting) prevented us from conducting our planned analyses on group verdict. Half of the guilty verdicts came from all-White juries evaluating a White defendant, and no all-White jury convicted a racialized defendant. Verdict change was not significantly predicted by either defendant race or jury composition. CONCLUSIONS: Deliberation elicited a leniency shift irrespective of defendant race. White jurors in all-White juries may have exhibited performative allyship, given the low cost of a potential wrongful acquittal in this simulation study. Findings have implications for jury research, in that our observed effects do not comport with real-world disparities between White and racialized defendants. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2026 APA, all rights reserved).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maeder et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: