Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter argues that relying on intraoperative sizers may replace essential preoperative planning in breast augmentation, suggesting risks in decision-making.
Intraoperative breast sizers can be useful adjuncts, but routine reliance on them risks substituting intraoperative trial for anatomy-based preoperative planning in primary breast augmentation. This letter argues that implant selection should be defined before incision through preoperative measurements and dimensional constraints, rather than deferred to the operating room. Deferring the definitive choice can encourage volume-driven thinking, despite the fact that identical volumes may correspond to markedly different implant geometries with different effects on footprint, projection, and long-term appearance. It may also compromise inframammary incision placement when the new inframammary fold is expected to differ from the pre-existing fold, increasing the risk of a scar that sits too high or too low relative to the final fold. Intraoperative assessment is additionally vulnerable to positioning artefacts in semi-sitting evaluation and to social influence within the operating room when multiple observers provide input during sizing. Finally, repeated insertion and removal of sizers increases device passes into the pocket, potentially increasing opportunities for bacterial transfer and pocket contamination. While sizers may be reasonable in selected situations, such as marked asymmetry when different implants are anticipated or mastopexy augmentation where temporary sizing can support shaping while limiting handling of the definitive implant, they should not become a default workflow. Sizers should assist, not replace, disciplined preoperative planning and decision-making.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Paolo Montemurro (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: