Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The paper develops a heuristic for understanding asymmetrical causality in QCA, enhancing causal explanations for outcomes.
Asymmetrical causality is a much underutilized strength of QCA (Qualitative Comparative Analysis). The heterogeneity of negative cases complicates interpreting the solution for ~ Y into a plausible, generalizable explanation. Moreover, QCA’s asymmetry is partial only, using the same conditions for Y and ~ Y. This paper develops a heuristic that overcomes these limitations. It interprets the solution for Y as causal powers ‘producing’ Y and the solution for ~ Y as constraints ‘blocking’ these causal powers. Researchers do not develop a causal explanation linking the presence of a configuration (cause) to ~ Y but interpret configurations in the solution for ~ Y as constraints for Y. That is, researchers do not explain the occurrence of ~ Y but the non-occurrence of Y. This circumvents the heterogeneity and partial asymmetry plaguing (causal) explanations for ~ Y in QCA and leads to deeper insights in the causes and constraints for Y, which is anyway the main focus of QCA studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roel Rutten (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: