Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Recent advances in generative artificial intelligence are compromising higher education non-exam assessments. AI detection and academic integrity procedures have proved insufficient for minimising AI misuse. Furthermore, employability skills development requires some use of AI by students in both learning and assessment, especially in the vocational sector. In this study, a solution is offered based on the design of new assessments (or redesign of existing ones) in alignment with a framework aimed at tertiary vocational education. Following a pragmatist approach, general recommendations and guidelines from universities are explored in a scoping review, followed by a detailed analysis of key concepts in contemporary assessment design where “critical thinking” and “creativity” are rejected as safeguards against AI misuse on the grounds of evidence in published literature. The proposed framework incorporates “context”, “collaboration/interaction”, “process” and “product” from the perspective of vocational authenticity, a concept also analysed in depth in relation to studies on authentic assessment. Practitioner evidence from the institutional context of this research is provided to discuss the implementation of these concepts from selected illustrative examples in applied management and other disciplines, with a particular emphasis on assessment criteria. Overall, this article presents a case for the rethinking of non-exam assessment security and validity in the age of AI.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bruno Balducci (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: