Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Assesses readability of visualizations for fault classification in non-specialists, suggesting effective communication.
Rolling-element bearings remain a leading cause of unplanned downtime in industrial machinery, while vibration-based condition monitoring has matured, the post-2018 literature has converged on machine-learning classifiers whose interpretability layer remains restricted to expert analysts. This paper presents an operator-centred visualization framework supported by two time-frequency methods: the Zhao–Atlas–Marks Distribution (ZAMD), a Cohen’s-class representation with a cross-term-suppressing cone kernel, and Complete Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition with Adaptive Noise (CEEMDAN), evaluated through its Hilbert spectral analysis output. Both methods produce two-dimensional time-frequency artefacts with a similar visual structure—impact-related energy bursts that recur at the characteristic fault frequencies—and are presented in side-by-side form for each fault class. A four-stage framework wraps either method with the characteristic fault frequencies (supplied as a comparison reference) and colour-coded, healthy baseline-referenced scaling. The framework is demonstrated on a laboratory bearing rig (KOYO 6302, 600 RPM) across inner-race, outer-race, and ball-spin fault classes. A preliminary readability assessment of annotated ZAMD-generated artefacts, with twelve non-specialist participants from a brewing and packaging industrial context, recorded 89.8% aggregate classification accuracy (194 of 216 trials) at a mean response time of 15.4 s. Because no label-free or alternative-format control conditions were included, this result characterises the annotated artefact as a whole and does not isolate the contribution of the time-frequency representation from that of the annotation layer; it is established for the ZAMD engine only. The two methods are compared as visualization engines—qualitatively, through the structure of their side-by-side time-frequency artefacts, and quantitatively, through computational cost—whereas the non-specialist readability assessment characterises the ZAMD-based framework specifically. CEEMDAN is positioned as a candidate alternative engine whose time-frequency output is shown to be structurally similar but whose operator readability has not been tested with human participants and is identified as future work.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tsiafis et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: