Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reveals limitations of single-component superfluid models in gravity contexts, suggesting further field exploration.
Superfluid-vacuum models of emergent gravity require a macroscopic radial inflow with the Painlevé–Gullstrand (PG) profile v(r) = √(2G_eff M/r), whose moving-frame acoustic metric is exactly Schwarzschild. This paper proves that in a single-component logarithmic superfluid vacuum this flow cannot be mechanically sourced by matter in any steady state. Three independent arguments converge. First, a continuity/multipole theorem: a flow v ∝ r^(−1/2) carries enclosed flux growing as r^(3/2), outside the space of fields producible by any localized source, conservative or non-conservative — the required space-filling sink has divergent total rate. A numerical mechanism zoo (point sinks, compressible sinks with the logarithmic equation of state, elastic dilatation centers, conversion sinks, and sink/anti-sink superpositions) confirms the wall: every finite-rate mechanism lands at r^(−2) or steeper. Second, the relativistic linearization about the background: the amplitude branch is gapped at ω_gap = c√(2b) — the healing/Planck scale — so the static density disturbance of any localized soliton heals as a Yukawa tail of Planckian range and cannot carry a long-range potential. The nonrelativistic reduction is shown to be modulationally unstable, making the relativistic treatment essential; both statements are verified numerically. Third, a Helmholtz decomposition crossed with the gap structure: the gapless sector of the condensate is the phase mode, whose long-range content is divergence-free circulation — electromagnetism — while the divergent radial flow gravity requires is tied by the Hamilton–Jacobi equation to a 1/r enthalpy profile that the gapped density sector forbids. The condensate's mechanically natural flows produce r^(−2), charge-like, cancellation-prone forces — electromagnetism, which the framework sources successfully — and not the escape-velocity flow of gravity: electromagnetism is the curl of the vacuum, gravity is its divergence, and only the curl is gapless. The transient loophole — an expanding infall front requiring no sink — is closed numerically: the inflow never approaches the PG profile and quenches on a sound-crossing timescale into the hydrostatic configuration, precisely the static channel the framework itself shows to be pathological. The theorem applies to the entire class of single-field superfluid-vacuum theories and carries a constructive prescription: mechanically sourced long-range gravity requires a second, gapless, compressible field, unifying this weak-field obstruction with the absence of a spin-2 sector in single-scalar models. All numerical results are reproduced by six self-contained scripts included with the deposit.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Boris Kulangiev (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: