Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Archival and field analysis reveals how agrarian realities are diminished in Malawi's food governance.
In Malawi, smallholder farmers are repeatedly positioned as central to food security and transformation, yet the knowledge through which they manage crops, labor, risk, soil, and markets is treated as insufficient to the futures policy imagines for them. We read that contradiction as one trace of agricultural gaslighting: a governance-scale process through which agrarian realities are invited, renamed, and narrowed. Drawing on archival and policy analysis, interviews with farmers, extension workers, and officials, participant observation, and bounded autoethnography, we trace a genealogy through which ‘native,’ ‘peasant,’ and later ‘smallholder’ farming are made to signify deficiency. The dynamic is reproduced through policy, agricultural education, extension, and data systems, and materialized through crop-input-market regimes of hybrid seed, chemical fertilizer, commercialization, and input subsidies. Recent Malawi policy is revealing: it acknowledges underperformance or implementation gaps, then renews a familiar remedy – more modernization, less Indigenous knowledge. Yet richer repertoires persist on farms: local maize, intercropping, madimba, and situated experimentation, valued for taste and storage; participatory and agroecological initiatives redistribute authority in bounded settings, though not yet the wider architecture. We argue that extractive agrarian governance works through land, labor, crops, and data – and, beyond these, through the production of agrarian reality itself.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Moyo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: