Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Framework assesses student abilities in AI-assisted assignments, indicating a shift towards skill-based evaluation.
Most frameworks for AI-assisted student work try to detect the tool. This one does the opposite. It assesses the student, not the prompt. • No AI detection needed.Works with or without tool disclosure.• Six-step workflow with a live competence check as the critical gate.• Aligned with ISO 21001 and ENQA/ESG standards. This paper proposes a generalized, cross-disciplinary framework for assessing student assignments produced with artificial intelligence, hybrid methods, or purely mental effort, without any declaration or weighting of the production method. The central claim is that assessment should judge the student's present ability to justify, transfer, and critically audit knowledge, rather than the causal history behind the production of the deliverable. The framework is grounded in the classical distinction between the context of discovery and the context of justification (Reichenbach, 1938, Popper, 1972), and is placed in dialogue with reliabilism (Goldman, 1979) and virtue/competence epistemology (Sosa, 1980, Zagzebski, 1996). At the practical level, a six-step workflow is proposed, with a live transfer check as its critical, universally applied gate, supported by an Instructional Support System (ISS) to offload instructor workload, and institutionally aligned with ISO 21001 and the ESG.This revised version (Version 2) corrects a proxy-fallacy in the original design, replaces sample-based scaling with universal modular coverage, defines the support system to prevent circularity, introduces equity-of-access safeguards and a formal appeals mechanism, and generalizes institutional alignment to a jurisdiction-neutral form suitable for the European Higher Education Area. The paper records its remaining limitations and proposes a pilot-implementation roadmap.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Markos Rizk (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: