Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The entry of generative artificial intelligence (AI) into knowledge-intensive professional practice unsettles a question older than the technology itself: who is entitled to claim authorship of their own work. Drawing on attribution theory, self-efficacy theory, self-discrepancy theory, and professional identity research, this article develops a theoretical construct, AI-Induced Imposter Syndrome (AI-IIS), to describe a cognitive condition in which professional competence is misattributed to AI systems rather than consolidated into the self-concept. A three-stage process model is advanced, though each stage is offered as a hypothesis under stress rather than a finished description. The first proposed stage, algorithmic attribution confusion, captures the uncertainty that arises when professionals cannot clearly parse the human-versus-AI origin of performance outcomes. The second, interrupted mastery consolidation, specifies a mechanism by which self-efficacy fails to develop when successes are attributed externally. The third, professional identity destabilisation, concerns the erosion of authorship, agency, and intentionality as pillars of occupational selfhood. AI-IIS is differentiated from six adjacent technology-psychology constructs – technostress, automation anxiety, algorithm aversion, skill atrophy concerns, general AI anxiety, and AI-induced shame and guilt – though the boundaries remain permeable, and empirical clarification of overlap is itself part of the research agenda. Seven formal propositions are advanced with operationalisation anchors, alongside a measurement development roadmap for a proposed AI-IIS Scale (AI-ISS). Multilevel intervention pathways spanning cognitive attribution retraining, the Companion Model of human–AI collaboration, and institutional AI Declaration Frameworks are framed as testable experimental hypotheses, not solutions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jamshaid et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: