Why the study?
Existing surgical technical skills assessment tools often suffer from poor development practices and lack robust validity data, with no structured, standardized surgical quality assurance framework published to guide the wider surgical community.
Introduces a joint EAES-SAGES framework to standardize the development of procedure-specific surgical quality assessment tools for competency-based training.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Competency-based training may refine surgical skill assessment; leaves open optimal metrics and patient outcome validation in trials.
Surgical training has traditionally relied on surrogate measures of technical competence, such as case numbers, supervising clinician recommendations, and performance in written and oral examinations.Consequently, most surgical training pathways have been time-based rather than competency-based.However, there is a growing shift globally towards competency-based training pathways which emphasise direct observation and assessment of technical and procedural skills.Competency-based surgical training pathways are now widely adopted, internationally recognised, and increasingly required for accreditation purposes.[1-4] Given the high-stakes nature of competency assessment within surgical training pathways, it is essential that tools used to assess technical skills are developed using rigorous methodologies and demonstrate adequate validity evidence.Despite this need, many existing technical skills assessment tools suffer from poor development practices and lack robust validity data [5,6].Although test development theory is well established in fields such as psychology and general education, its application within surgical competency assessment remains inconsistent.Technical skills assessments in surgery face unique challenges, including differing surgical techniques between surgeons and institutions, variation in surgeon competence and heterogeneity of human anatomy.These challenges, combined with the current shortcomings in procedural competency assessment tool (CAT) development, underscore the need for robust and standardised surgical quality assurance (SQA) processes.SQA broadly encompasses test definition, procedure standardisation, CAT development, and implementation [7,8].While the development of SQA and CAT has been applied within clinical trials, a structured standardised SQA framework is yet to be published to guide the wider surgical community [9], Tsai et al., 2019;[10] in the systematic development, validation, and application of procedure-specific tools for surgical video assessment.Currently, there is a fragmented approach to CAT development across surgical societies and institutions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Campioni-Norman et al. (2026) studied Surgical competency assessment. EAES-SAGES Surgical Quality Assurance (SQA) framework was evaluated on Establishment of a unified EAES-SAGES best practice SQA framework for developing procedure-specific competency assessment tools. The EAES and SAGES societies established a unified, consensus-driven Surgical Quality Assurance framework to standardize the development of procedure-specific competency assessment tools.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: