Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
The effectiveness of controlling nitrogen (N) loading (in addition to phosphorus P) to manage the eutrophication of aquatic ecosystems has been debated despite the role of N in producing algal biomass and toxins. Long-term, controlled tests of the efficacy of N loading reductions are largely missing from the scientific record, perhaps due to the historical focus on P control. To address this knowledge gap, we examined the results from a unique, long-term study conducted in 24 flow-through (2.5-month retention time) lake ecosystem-scale mesocosms in Denmark, operating since 2003 at two contrasting nutrient loading levels crossed with three temperature scenarios (ambient, IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) A2 scenario, and A2+50%). For 1 year, the N loading, apart from groundwater inputs, was stopped in high nutrient loading mesocosms, while P loading was maintained. We followed the changes in key environmental variables and system metabolism for 5 years, including the 2 years prior to N loading reduction and 2 years after N loading resumption. The low nutrient loading treatments, which only received N and P from groundwater, were used as a reference. We found a strong effect of N loading on total N (TN), N oxides (NO 2 + NO 3 ), and N:P ratios. After reducing the excess external N loading, which had lasted for 15 years, TN and N oxides declined to similar levels as those in the low nutrient treatments at all temperature scenarios and increased quickly when N loading was resumed. Algal biomass (as chlorophyll a ) and ecosystem production and respiration were also affected. The results showed (1) a rapid response of water N concentrations to external N loading, (2) major ecosystem effects, including reduced algal biomass and system metabolism, and (3) overall low sensitivity in response to the IPCC temperature scenarios. This study was conducted under semi-natural conditions, providing strong experimental support for the key role of N at the ecosystem level in shallow lakes. Our results have profound implications for lake management and suggest that external N loading reductions may strengthen the recovery of shallow lakes from eutrophication.
Jeppesen et al. (Mon,) studied this question.