Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Figural matrices typically consist of multiple distinct logical rules, requiring test-takers to disengage from one rule before applying the next. Prior studies have consistently shown moderate associations between matrix performance and task-switching ability. However, these findings are largely based on correlational data. The present two-study article aimed to (a) determine, on a theoretical level, whether task-switching ability is functionally involved in matrix processing, and (b) assess, from a diagnostic perspective, whether relaxing the constraint of distinct rules within a single matrix threatens psychometric validity. To this end, we manipulated matrices to include both distinct-rule and identical-rule transitions, enabling experimental within-subject comparisons of matrix processing in both conditions based on log file analyses. In study 1 ( N = 209), task-switching ability exerted a functional influence only during distinct-rule transitions. However, the correlation between task-switching ability and matrix performance remained comparably strong even during identical-rule transitions. This dual pattern supports both a switch-dependency hypothesis (i.e., that task-switching is functionally involved in matrix processing) and a shared-resource hypothesis (i.e., that task-switching and matrix processing draw on a common cognitive resource). In study 2 ( N = 258), we evaluated the convergent validity of the newly designed mixed-rule format against the traditional distinct-rule format. Test scores were highly correlated ( r = 0.87), and test characteristics (e.g., reliability, IRT and TIF parameters) and external validity were very similar. Taken together, these findings suggest that although task-switching demands can vary depending on matrix design, relaxing rule constraints does not compromise psychometric validity. This flexibility in item development may be particularly useful in large-scale assessments or student selection tests that require continuous item renewal.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Weber et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: