Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Comparative study demonstrates deep learning models outperform classical detectors for microseismic discrimination in geothermal monitoring, suggesting improved accuracy.
Microseismic event discrimination in distributed acoustic sensing data is critical for monitoring enhanced geothermal system operations, yet classical detectors based on short-term to long-term energy ratios, in the simple validation-tuned form evaluated here, fail to discriminate genuine seismic arrivals from structured noise. This paper presents a comparative study of twelve artificial intelligence models based on deep learning, spanning five architecture families—convolutional neural networks, transformers, recurrent networks, state-space models, and graph neural networks—benchmarked against three classical baselines on 3974 manually labeled distributed acoustic sensing recordings from a field stimulation campaign. We contribute an open-source labeling tool for multichannel seismic data, and evaluate complete 1.2-second triggered candidate-window classification rather than end-to-end continuous-stream detection. A preliminary temporal-context ablation is reported but not treated as a repeated-seed conclusion. The squeeze-and-excitation residual network and the plain residual network are statistically comparable; the squeeze-and-excitation variant has the highest numerical F1-score (the harmonic mean of precision and recall), 98.50%, and an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 99.46%, while the plain residual network has slightly stronger balanced accuracy and noise recall under the exported reviewer metrics. A selective state-space model achieves 95.76% F1-score, providing a competitive baseline for this architecture family in this dataset. A graph neural network exploiting fiber spatial topology achieves 95.47% F1-score with only 94,290 parameters. Gradient-weighted class activation mapping provides qualitative evidence that the convolutional models focus on primary-wave moveout patterns. To stress-test external transfer, all twelve saved Stage 14 models are evaluated without fine-tuning on Utah Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy April 2024 data, a different acquisition. The external set contains 4073 candidate windows (2024 event windows and 2049 non-event windows). The native records have 1496 traces and 4800 samples at 4000 samples per second; the same preprocessing function was used for event and non-event windows: the first 361 traces were retained, the records were downsampled to 2400 samples at 2000 samples per second using anti-aliased polyphase resampling, and per-channel z-score (zero mean, unit variance) normalization was applied. The best external model is the convolutional neural network–gated recurrent unit hybrid with F1-score 0.9930, balanced accuracy 0.9931, and Matthews correlation coefficient 0.9863. We interpret this as zero-shot evidence of matched-pipeline external robustness, not as universal cross-site validation or deployment-ready generalization. A three-seed retraining of the top two residual convolutional models with full random-state control further confirms that the small numerical F1 advantage of SE-ResNet over ResNet is within initialization variance: the pooled inter-seed standard deviation ( σ ≈ 0.0036 F1) is approximately four times the inter-model mean difference (0.0009 F1), and paired t -tests and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests fail to reject the null of no difference on F1, balanced accuracy, and MCC.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rahaman et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: