Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Previous articleNext article FreeInternational Reserves and Underdeveloped Capital MarketsKathryn M. E. DominguezKathryn M. E. DominguezUniversity of Michigan and NBER Search for more articles by this author PDFPDF PLUSFull Text Add to favoritesDownload CitationTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints Share onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmailQR Code SectionsMoreI. IntroductionChina's official foreign exchange reserves have passed the $2 trillion mark, equivalent to approximately $2,000 for every Chinese citizen.1 Although China is currently the country with the largest foreign reserve accumulation, reserves have risen dramatically for many developing countries in recent years. Economic models suggest a number of motivations for reserve accumulation, including precautionary and mercantilist motives, which may be especially compelling for developing countries. However, the recent upsurge in reserve accumulation among developing countries cannot be explained solely on the basis of these rationales. This paper examines a potential new role for reserve accumulation in helping to mitigate distortions created by the undeveloped financial markets of developing countries.The growth and liberalization of financial markets in industrial countries over the past three decades provide developing countries unprecedented access to international capital markets and expose them to sometimes dramatic and sudden swings in capital flows. The 1990s witnessed a number of economic crises in developing countries that were accompanied by (if not precipitated by) outflows of international capital. This recent experience with capital flow reversals can, at least in part, explain the desire by developing countries to decrease their dependence on international capital by accumulating foreign reserves.While global financial markets have recently been tumultuous, the trend has been for financial markets in industrial countries to deepen and broaden at the same time that markets in many developing countries remain incomplete. This paper focuses on the implications for developing countries of underdeveloped capital markets. In a series of papers, Ricardo Caballero and coauthors have developed models showing that underdeveloped capital markets cause undervaluation of international resources by the private sector, which encourages excessive external borrowing, dollarization of international liabilities, and other actions that increase their exposure to potential capital shortfalls (see, e.g., Caballero and Krishnamurthy 2001, 2004, 2005). One way to mitigate the costs of this exposure is for developing country governments to accumulate international reserves.2The analysis in this paper considers the role of financial market underdevelopment in motivating reserve accumulation by developing countries, while also allowing for the more traditional mercantilist and precautionary motives. In theory there can be a strict distinction between the precautionary motive, which seeks to smooth consumption fluctuations, and the underdeveloped financial markets motive, which seeks to offset a tightening of a financial constraint. However, in practice, these two motivations for reserve accumulation may be difficult to disentangle. In particular, the desire to smooth intertemporal consumption is likely to be influenced by financial market constraints. Whereas Aiyagari (1994) in a closed economy framework suggests that for the U.S. private sector precautionary savings are likely to be sufficient to relax financial constraints, this is less likely to be the case in developing countries in which distortions may bias the private sector against saving, thereby providing incentives for the public sector to step in.Official foreign exchange reserve holdings by developing countries greatly exceed those of industrial countries (in the case of China, in absolute terms, and in most other cases relative to the sizes of their economies). This is yet another example of the capital flows paradox described by Lucas (1990). Capital should flow to where its return is highest, which ought to be where capital is scare. If instead capital flows from the capital‐poor developing world to the capital‐rich industrialized world, the explanation is likely to be found in distortions not entertained in standard models.II. Motives for the Accumulation of International ReservesInternational reserves held by government authorities are part of national wealth and were originally important for countries with fixed exchange rates that wanted to avoid costly adjustments to disturbances in the external sector of the economy. For example, if a country ran a current account deficit, reserves could be used by the government to forestall an exchange rate depreciation that might otherwise occur. However, in this view of reserves, as a country's level of wealth increases over time or if a country moves away from a fixed exchange rate regime, it is less clear how much of a share of the national wealth should be devoted to international reserve assets.Heller (1966) provides one of the first attempts at calculating an optimal country‐specific level of international reserves based on what he termed the precautionary motive. The three parameters he thought important to this calculation include (1) the cost of adjusting to an external imbalance (measured as the propensity to import), (2) the cost of holding liquid international reserves (measured as the difference between the return on the reserves relative to a benchmark return on domestic bonds), and (3) the probability that there will actually be a need for reserves of a given magnitude (based on the history of past external imbalances).In the period following the 1971 breakdown of the Bretton Woods System, while many industrial countries moved away from fixed exchange rate systems toward more flexible regimes, countries continued to hold reserves despite the disappearance of their original purpose, which was to help finance current account imbalances. In practice there seem to have evolved a number of "rules of thumb" to determine optimal reserve levels loosely based on Heller's precautionary motive. These rules included maintaining reserves equivalent to (1) 3 months of imports (to offset current account shocks), (2) 5%–20% of M2 (to be able to shore up confidence in the value of the domestic currency in the event of a currency crisis), and (3) the value of all debt obligations falling due within the following year (in the event of a sudden disappearance of short‐term capital inflows).3All these rules of thumb imply a desire on the part of governments to acquire reserves to serve as a cushion against adverse economic shocks of one form or another and as such can be categorized as satisfying Heller's precautionary motive. Frenkel and Jovanovic (1981) provide a more formal approach to modeling the precautionary motive for holding reserves using a stochastic inventory‐theoretic framework. Their model indicates that optimal reserve holdings increase with the volatility of reserves (which are presumably influenced by current account shocks, the value of the domestic currency, and capital inflows) subject to a fixed cost of reserve accumulation and the opportunity cost of holding reserves. Ben‐Bassat and Gottlieb (1992) follow in this buffer stock modeling tradition while also linking international reserves with sovereign risk.4An alternative view of reserve accumulation is that it is the by‐product of a government strategy to keep the international value of the domestic currency low in order to boost export growth. In this view purchases of foreign reserves are not motivated by a desire to smooth consumption in the face of external shocks, but rather they are the unintended consequence of sterilized interventions in the foreign exchange market.5 This rationale for reserve accumulation, typically labeled the mercantilist motive, has been advanced by Dooley, Folkerts‐Landau, and Garber (2003) as a description of the development strategy followed by many East Asian countries, particularly China.There have been a number of recent empirical studies attempting to measure whether the precautionary or mercantilist motive better explains foreign reserve accumulations by both industrialized and developing countries. These studies generally find evidence in support of both motivations (see, e.g., Aizenman and Lee 2007), while at the same time finding that neither motivation fully explains the recent upsurge in reserve accumulations by developing countries (Jeanne 2007; Jeanne and Ranciere 2009). As figure 1 indicates, any theory of official reserve accumulation that hopes to explain the recent data will need to match the timing of the dramatic increase in reserve accumulations by developing countries over the 1990s and early 2000s. Even if we allow for an increase in precautionary holdings in the aftermath of the developing country crises of the 1990s, studies suggest that current reserve accumulations far exceed warranted levels (Jeanne 2007).6Fig. 1. Foreign reserves as a percentage of GDP, 1977–2004. Source: Lane and Milesi‐Ferretti (2007), external wealth of nations database.View Large ImageDownload PowerPointTable 1 presents data from the financial accounts of industrialized and developing countries over the period 1990–2004. For developing countries, over 40% of foreign asset accumulation consists of official reserves, whereas for industrialized countries official reserves make up only 2% of gross foreign assets. Figure 2 provides a time‐series view of the decomposition of foreign assets for developing countries over time. The figure highlights the increasing relative importance of official reserve accumulation for developing countries especially since 2000. On the liability side, developing countries rely much more heavily on foreign direct investment (FDI) than the industrialized countries do.7 Figure 3 depicts official reserves as a fraction of net FDI liabilities, in which the recent dramatic upsurge in reserves evident in figure 1 for developing countries (where reserves are measured as a fraction of GDP) is no longer apparent. Hence if one views reserves in the context of private‐sector (FDI) liabilities, the trend patterns of reserve accumulation across industrial and developing countries are no longer so starkly divergent.Table 1. Reserve Accumulation and the Financial Account, 1990–2004Financial Account CategoryIndustrialCountriesDevelopingCountriesComposition of the increase in gross foreign assets: FDI22.9014.87 Portfolio19.199.99 Other55.6433.38 Reserves2.2741.76Composition of the increase in gross foreign liabilities: FDI19.3541.57 Portfolio19.2520.06 Other61.4138.37BIS decomposition of foreign liabilities: Public22.0830.49 Private77.9269.51Source: International Monetary Fund, Balance of Payments Statistics, and Bank for International Settlements (BIS).View Table Image: 1 | 2Fig. 2. Foreign reserves and net liabilities for developing countries, 1977–2004 (billions of U.S. dollars). Source: Lane and Milesi‐Ferretti (2007), external wealth of nations database.View Large ImageDownload PowerPointFig. 3. Foreign reserves as a share of net FDI liabilities, 1977–2004. Source: Lane and Milesi‐Ferretti (2007), external wealth of nations database.View Large ImageDownload PowerPointUnderlying most standard models of economic growth is the assumption that investment leads to capital accumulation, which in turn leads to higher levels of production. It is therefore instructive to consider how measures of capital flows (as shown in the cross‐country financial accounts reported in Table 1) are related to aggregate investment rates. Chen (2007) shows that higher investment rates are associated with lower net capital inflows for developing countries. Further, the component of capital flows that is driving this counterintuitive result is official foreign reserves. Figure 4 presents a cross‐country scatter plot of investment rates and reserve holdings showing a significant positive relationship for developing countries. A similar scatter plot for industrialized countries shows no relationship between investment and reserves.Fig. 4. Investment and foreign reserves for developing countries. Source: International Financial Statistics and World Development Indicators; investment/GDP and reserves/GDP are averages over 1980–2001, from Chen (2007).View Large ImageDownload PowerPointThe negative relationship between rates of investment and capital inflows for developing countries most likely reflects credit constraints. The pace of financial market development, like reserve accumulation, has diverged markedly between industrialized countries, where markets have generally deepened and broadened, and developing countries, where this deepening has yet to take place. It seems reasonable to hypothesize that in countries with underdeveloped capital markets the private sector faces constraints on its ability to borrow. In this situation the government's accumulation of reserves may act as a substitute for what would otherwise be private‐sector capital outflows. The next section presents a simple model to help clarify the role of reserve accumulation in loosening financial constraints for countries with less developed financial markets.III. A Simple Model of Private‐Sector External UnderinsuranceIt is useful to start with a simple example to highlight the problem of underinsurance by the private sector in developing countries. Consider an economy over three periods with a single consumption good. In period 0 firms make initial investments, in period 1 some firms need to reinvest as part of the normal restructuring of an economy, and in period 2 the output is produced.In period 1 the firms that need to make additional investments will be able to produce less than otherwise, though with full reinvestment all firms produce the same output. Those firms that need to reinvest finance this by borrowing and must provide their creditors with collateral. If we make the realistic assumption that domestic lenders allow some fraction of domestic plant and equipment to serve as collateral, whereas foreign lenders do not, collateral is limited in an asymmetric way; firms will have less access to foreign lenders than they do to domestic lenders. In this simple setup the supply of loans can be assumed to be elastic where the domestic and foreign interest rates are equalized, up to the point that firms borrow the maximum available from foreigners and beyond this point the supply of loans is completely inelastic.8 The domestic interest rate in period 1 lies above the foreign interest rate, as a consequence of the more binding collateral constraint on foreign borrowing, and below the marginal product of full reinvestment.If firms know that they may be financially constrained in period 1, they should optimally borrow less in period 0 in order to save resources. Yet the model suggests that firms will not insure themselves against this potential financing constraint. Why not? The problem is that the return to savings in period 0 does not reflect the true marginal product of financing in period 1 because of the distortions caused by collateral constraints. In equilibrium, external financing is undervalued, and as a consequence firms will be underinsured against potential capital shortfalls.There are a number of possible solutions to the underinsurance problem, at least in theory. The key is to find a way to bring the ex post price of international resources in line with the marginal product of reinvestment. One such solution is reserve accumulation by the government. In this case, governments purchase international bonds and sterilize the effects of this purchase on the home money supply by issuing domestic bonds. If the interest rate offered on these domestic bonds in period 0 is higher than the period 1 domestic interest rate, the government is essentially subsidizing savings in period 0, which is exactly what is needed to mitigate the underinsurance problem.IV. Empirical Evidence Connecting Reserve Accumulation, Private‐Sector Underinsurance, and Financial Market UnderdevelopmentThis simple model provides two important predictions for reserve‐accumulating countries. The first implication is that these countries will exhibit private‐sector underinsurance against future capital shortfalls. The second implication is that there will be a wedge between the collateral value of domestic projects in the home country and international valuations of the same projects. In practice, while cross‐country data on private‐ and public‐sector external debt are available, data measuring the "collateral wedge" are not. There is, however, a large literature focused on the measurement of financial market development that is likely to be directly related to collateral constraints (see, e.g., Beck, Demirgüç‐Kunt, and Levine 2000). This literature provides a number of suggested measures of financial market (under)development including financial openness (Chinn and Ito 2006), money and quasi money supply as a percentage of GDP (Lane and Burke 2001; Obstfeld et al. 2008), and the sum of private credit creation and stock market capitalization (Chinn and Ito 2009). Another measure of financial market development is the extent of external liabilities, based on the assumption that countries with less developed domestic financial markets also have fewer external liabilities. Figure 5 shows one such measure of financial development (fin_dev1) that sums foreign portfolio equity and debt liabilities divided by GDP for industrialized and developing countries over the period 1977–2004.9 The figure shows that while this measure of financial markets has increased steadily in the industrialized countries, the growth rate of financial markets has been substantially slower for developing countries. It is also the case that the divergence in growth rates between the two groups of countries widens at around the same time as reserve accumulation by developing countries starts to accelerate.Fig. 5. Financial market development, fin_dev1, 1977–2004 (based on the size of foreign equity and debt liabilities). Source: Lane and Milesi‐Ferretti (2007), external wealth of nations database; measured as the sum of foreign equity and debt liabilities over GDP; excludes Luxembourg.View Large ImageDownload PowerPointAn alternative measure of financial market development (fin_dev2) focuses on the size of domestic financial markets. Figure 6, which measures financial development as the sum of a country's domestic private credit creation and stock market capitalization as a ratio of GDP, shows again the widening divergence between industrialized and developing countries in the late 1990s. Interestingly, this measure of domestic financial market size rises for industrialized countries (and to some extent developing countries) earlier than is apparent in figure 5, which is based on external rather than domestic liabilities.Fig. 6. Financial market development, fin_dev2, 1988–2004 (based on domestic market size). Source: World Bank database on financial development and structure, measured as the sum of a country's private credit creation and stock market capitalization as a ratio of GDP.View Large ImageDownload PowerPointYet another measure of financial markets, focused more narrowly on the banking sector, is the ratio of money and quasi money to GDP. Obstfeld et al. (2008) make the case that the primary reason for reserve accumulation is to protect the domestic banking sector during periods of capital flight. In their view, financial development increases the need for reserves because it allows domestic residents to convert domestic bank deposits into foreign exchange, leading to both a run on the banking system and a depreciation of the domestic currency. Figure 7 depicts the ratio of M2 to GDP for industrialized and developing countries, which shows a steady upward trend for developing countries over this time period.Fig. 7. Ratio of M2 money supply to GDP, 1980–2004. Source: World Development Indicators; excludes Euro Zone countries after 1999.View Large ImageDownload PowerPointFinancial market development need not be measured only in terms of the size of markets or deposits; presumably the quality of institutions within a country will also influence the depth and breadth of markets. Cheung and Ito (2009) focus on the relationship between a number of country‐specific institutional variables (corruption, bureaucratic quality, law and order, form of government, government fractionalization) and reserve accumulation and find weak evidence for their importance. One potential explanation is that many of these indicators do not change, or change only infrequently in some countries. In the empirical work to follow, country fixed effects are included to capture these time‐invariant institutional differences.In the empirical literature that attempts to estimate reserve holdings for panels of countries based on mercantilist and precautionary motives,10 the standard regression specification includes scale factors (GDP), an indicator of exchange rate flexibility, indicators of openness and vulnerability to external shocks, the share of imports in GDP, and the ratio of M2 to GDP.11 Column 1 of Table 2 presents the results of a panel regression that includes 56 (industrialized and developing)12 countries over the 1977–2004 time period using this standard specification: where R is holdings of foreign reserves valued in logged millions of U.S. dollars (from Lane and Milesi‐Ferretti 2007), ExRate is an exchange rate classification based on the Reinhart and Rogoff (2004) de facto regimes, CC measures financial account openness (capital controls) based on Chinn and Ito's (2006) classifications, Crisis indicates the dates of currency crises as defined by Frankel and Rose (1996), CurOver indicates currency overvaluation relative to purchasing power parity (PPP), ShImp is the share of imports of goods and services in GDP, and ShM2 is the ratio of M2 to GDP. The panel estimation includes country fixed effects (so that coefficients are estimated from the time‐series variation within countries).Table 2. Panel Regressions Explaining Reserve Holdings Based on Precautionary, Mercantilist, and Financial Market Underdevelopment Motivations (Country Fixed Effects) StandardSpecification:Precautionaryand MercantilistMotives(1)Add: Privateand PublicLiabilities(2)Add: Measureof ExternalLiabilitiesa(fin_dev1)(3)Add: Measureof DomesticLiabilitiesb(fin_dev2)(4)Constant−7.20***(.46)−5.51***(.52)−4.84***(.52)−6.84***(.64)GDP1.30***(.04).84***(.06).73***(.06).84***(.07)Exchange rate regime−.06(.49).03(.04)−.002(.04)−.04(.05)Capital controls (kaopen)−.07***(.02).003(.02)−.008(.01).004(.02)Crisis dummy−.37***(.08)−.27***(.07)−.26***(.07)−.28***(.07)Currency overvaluation−.007***(.001)−.007***(.001)−.007***(.001)−.005***(.001)Share of imports1.81***(.25)1.31***(.23)1.54***(.23)1.02***(.29)Share of M2.49***(.13).43***(.12).37***(.11).73***(.15)Public liabilities −.05*(.03)−.02*(.01)−.07**(.03)Private liabilities .46***(.03).50***(.03).53***(.04)Financial market development −.38***(.06)−.21***(.05)Country fixed effectsYesYesYesYesR2 within.72.77.78.77R2 between.78.81.82.83Time observations1,0171,0171,017712Number of countries50505049Note: Robust standard errors clustered by country are in parentheses. See app. C for explanations of the variables and data sources.a. This measure of financial market development is based on each country's foreign equity and bond liabilities (graphed in fig. 5).b. This measure of financial market development is based on each country's domestic equity and bond liabilities (graphed in fig. 6); this measure is not available for China and is also unavailable for a number of countries prior to 1988 (see app. C for details).*Significant at the 90% confidence level.**Significant at the 95% confidence level.***Significant at the 99% confidence level.View Table Image: 1 | 2The results from this standard regression specification suggest that the various explanatory variables enter with the expected signs. Wealthier countries hold more reserves than poorer countries. Countries that have more open capital markets (potentially making them more vulnerable to sudden stops) hold more reserves. The indicator of currency crises suggests, as expected, that those countries experiencing crises held fewer reserves during their crises. Those countries whose exchange rate is "undervalued" relative to PPP, have higher shares of imports relative to GDP, and have higher ratios of M2 to GDP hold more 2 and 3 in Table 2 include additional variables suggested by the potential role of underdeveloped financial markets in reserve accumulation by developing countries. One that in this context is how to for the precautionary motive and ShM2 from those that reflect financial market The precautionary motive for holding reserves from the desire to smooth consumption distortions in the face of sudden reversals of international capital it may be that those countries
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kathryn M.E. Dominguez (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: