Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Debates as to whether pathological gambling (PG) is closer in nature to substance abuse disorders (SUDs) than obsessive compulsive disorders (OCDs), as well as discussions regarding the appropriateness of concepts such as addiction, impulsivity and compulsivity in describing the disorder, are timely and interesting in the context of the DSM-V's proposed reclassification of the syndrome 1. However, in conducting these debates it is important not to lose sight of the ‘big picture’, and to remember that these discussions derive from a very specific, medicalized perspective which cannot, alone, account for the existence or nature of PG. In particular, this perspective is based on shared assumptions about the individual (as opposed to the social or environmental) basis for problematic behaviour, whether this happens to be lodged in psychiatric or physiological factors, and on the correspondingly individual basis for solutions to those problems 2. It is crucial to adopt a broad perspective in the consideration of PG, which is a complex syndrome, and one that is sensitive to wider social, economic and political forces. In particular, the regulatory and policy environments that determine the availability and saturation of gambling opportunities, as well as the nature of gambling products themselves, have a determinant effect on the prevalence and aetiology of gambling problems 3-5. For instance, PG varies according to availability and type of game, and it also has differential impacts according to demographic group. A clear, albeit complex, relationship exists between increasing availability and/or density of gambling opportunities and increased levels of problems associated with gambling 6, 7. This is especially so when continuous, high-tech forms of gambling—such as electronic gaming machines (EGMs)—that are dispersed throughout local communities are involved 8-10. Australia, for example, has some of the highest rates of gambling-related problems in the world. It also has the highest concentrations of EGMs and these, as well as levels of PG, vary by state, with Victoria—which has a high concentrations of machines—reporting considerably higher rates of PG among its populations than Western Australia, which has reduced numbers of machines as well as lower levels of PG 11, 12. Similar relationships exist between the intensity of the local gambling environment and levels of harm throughout populations in other mature gambling markets. In Britain, for instance, the prevalence of PG remained stable at approximately 0.6% until the 2005 Gambling Act increased opportunities to gamble, when rates rose to around 0.9% 13. In addition, PG is characterized by an unequal socio-economic and geographic distribution of harms. Individuals from lower-income and ethnic minority groups and communities, as well as recent migrants and young males, suffer higher rates of PG than the general population 12, 14-16. Linked to this, the distribution of gambling problems also mirrors the geographic distribution of social deprivation, with research from Australia showing that the greater the socio-economic disadvantage of a municipality, the higher its numbers of gaming machines, with residents of the most deprived areas in a region spending almost double the state's average on them 17. Other research has also found that gambling problems are associated strongly with neighbourhood disadvantage as well as with the presence of gambling opportunities, with those who live within 10 miles of a casino having approximately double the rates of PG than those who live further afield 18, 19. Explanations for PG that are based solely on neurobiological or psychiatric factors cannot account for this kind of social patterning. Such unequal demographic and geographic distributions of pathology requires consideration of wider structural measures, such as state policies and regulatory environments. This broader perspective also has implications for interventions. Prevention and treatment measures need to involve a focus upon, for example, the availability of gambling opportunities, as well as upon the features of gambling products themselves, rather than simply upon pharmacological or behavioural interventions directed at individual pathological gamblers. Whatever classificatory system or nomenclature is used ultimately to describe PG, the fact remains that at the population level the latter is a complex behaviour that arises as a result of various social, political and economic, as well as individual, processes. Debates about the relative merits of OCD and SUD as applied to PG are interesting, but their value will be diminished if they are not considered alongside these wider environmental perspectives. GR is a member of the Responsible Gambling Strategy Board.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gerda Reith (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: