Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Tests the coherence between temperature and E-mode polarisation, suggesting shared alignment implications.
The hemispherical power asymmetry (HPA), a persistent anomaly of the CMB temperature, has a preferred axis; the analogous asymmetry in Planck’s E-mode polarisation lies near it — an alignment the Planck Collaboration noted could be coincidental. We test that fluke hypothesis. Planck’s two half-mission E-mode dipole directions, which share the sky but not the noise, agree to 8.7◦; coherence places the direction on the sky but cannot distinguish modulation from chance. The two hypotheses separate in alignment: a modulation imprints one axis on temperature and polarisation, whereas chance relates the temperature and E-mode directions only through the ΛCDM TE correlation. We test both jointly through a single scalar — the larger of the two half-mission distances to the temperature axis, small only when both independently-noised halves point near it — ranked against isotropic simulations and realisations constrained to the observed temperature sky. In PR3 Commander data it is 17.5◦: no realisation in either 300-member ensemble reaches it (𝑝 < 0.33%), nor does an 𝐴 = 0.07 modulation scored against its own axis — tighter than either chance or the simplest alternative produces. Coherence and alignment are confined to E-modes and reproduced by four component-separation methods; the odd–even split, of limited power at Planck noise, is consistent with both hypotheses (𝑝 = 16%). All p-values are conditional on the FFP10 noise model. The test identifies a shared axis, not its mechanism. It discriminates only while noise dominates the directions; deeper data instead measure the alignment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert A. Lynch (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: