Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Teaching hydrogeology is challenging; students must learn to mentally synthesize data from well logs, geologic cross sections, and contaminant concentrations to produce a scientifically plausible conceptual model of groundwater flow and contaminant migration. Identifying when and how students struggle in learning challenging content is key to designing instruction that turns these struggles into productive learning. As part of a larger project that identified relevant spatial thinking skills in hydrogeology, this study sought to identify components of a spatially intensive hydrogeology task that were most problematic for students and to characterize student struggles with those components. Using a descriptive, qualitative research design, we videoed eleven student groups (of two to three upper-level geoscience students each) as they completed the hydrogeology task. Combined elements of a think-aloud and traditional interview that incorporated manipulatives and gestures, used probing questions, and prompted discussion between students, elicited students’ spatial and conceptual reasoning. We integrated data sources to create observation notes as our main unit of analysis, to which we applied a coding scheme that captured salient aspects of student understanding and struggle. Of the seven coding categories, only one—working with a potentiometric surface—yielded more coded struggles than codes for understanding. Students struggled with defining the potentiometric surface, drawing the potentiometric surface, and describing the potentiometric surface in three dimensions. We use a spatial thinking lens to discuss why potentiometric surfaces are so challenging for students and offer implications for educators and possible directions for future research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Petcovic et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: