Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Granular filters are used in earth structures, such as embankment dams, to protect fine soils from erosion due to seepage forces. Successful filtration requires that the filter voids are fine enough to capture some of the coarse fraction of the base soil. These retained particles are then able to capture progressively finer base soil particles, and eventually a filter interface forms that is able to prevent any further erosion. This process is called self-filtration. Lafleur et al. (1989) examined self-filtration in cohesionless, broadly graded base soils. It was found that the extent of mass loss before self-filtration occurs was greater in broadly graded materials: hence a finer filter was required to reduce this mass loss. Filters for cohesive base soils are commonly designed using the Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) design criteria. While these criteria have been developed from extensive laboratory data, they may not be applicable to all fine base soils, particularly broadly graded materials.In this paper, a series of filtration tests on various base soils are described. Data from the current study, and the published results of laboratory tests from several sources are compared to examine the filtration of broadly graded base soils. Based on this analysis, a new design procedure is proposed for filters to protect fine base soils, which determines the ability of the coarse fraction of the base soil to retain the fine fraction (i.e. a self-filtering base soil).The test for no erosion filter—sometimes called the NEF test—was first proposed by Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) to determine the effectiveness of a filter protecting a base soil from erosion. In the test, the base soil sample is compacted against a filter, and a pinhole is driven through the base soil. Water under high pressure is forced through the pinhole, initiating erosion of the pinhole walls. The filter is considered successful if the pinhole shows no visible enlargement after a 20 min test. The coarsest successful filter is called the NEF boundary filter, or critical filter, represented by D15bdy. Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) divided base soils in the NEF test into four groups based on the quantity of fines. The finest two groups are: NEF tests have been performed on 15 samples of core materials from embankment dams within Australia and other sources. Representative base soil particle sizes and the NEF critical filters are presented in Table 1. In this paper, d refers to a base soil particle size, and D refers to a filter particle size. The critical filter sizes, D15bdy, determined from the current experiments are plotted against the d85 base soil particle size in Fig. 1. Also shown are the critical filters from published data of 33 NEF tests conducted by: The Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) design criteria are shown as a solid line in Fig. 1. Most of the lab data meet, or are very close to, the design criteria, the notable exception being material AP1, which has a safe critical filter size significantly finer than that required by the design criteria. This material has a ratio D15bdy/d85 = 1·1. Most of the group 2 materials plot below the line D15F = 9d85B, where the subscripts ‘F’ and ‘B’ stand for the filter and base soil respectively in the original Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) criteria (Fig. 1). The intention here is to investigate why a sharp demarcation occurs between the safe filter boundaries for group 1 and 2 materials, and why material AP1 has such a fine D15bdy.A new method to determine the self-filtering fraction of a broadly graded base soil, called the reduced PSD method, is described in this section, based on an analysis of the AP1 material. The particle size distribution (PSD) of the AP1 material is shown in Fig. 2. The fine critical filter for this material (D15bdy = 0·19 mm) and broad grading suggest that the coarse fraction of material AP1 is unable to retain the fine fraction: hence self-filtering does not occur. To determine the self-filtering fine fraction, the PSD is divided at some point n (where n is the percentage passing diameter dn), and one can then define d15 of the coarse fraction and d85 of the fine fraction to be (1)d15coarse=dn+0·15(100−n)(2)d85fine=d0·85nBertram (1940) with guidance from Terzaghi conducted detailed laboratory testing to determine if the coarse fraction is able to retain the fine fraction. For an effective filter including self-filtering ability, a conservative expression was found as: (3)d15coarsed85fine≤5This method is shown graphically in Fig. 3. Figure 3 is a semi-log plot: the vertical axis is not logarithmic, and the multipliers of n (e.g. 0·85n) will not be affected by the log scale.The PSD should be divided at some point n, and equation (3) is then checked to determine whether this part of the PSD is stable. As an example, data from Fig. 2 for the AP1 material imply that when n = 50%, d15coarse = 0·011 mm and d85fine = 0·007 mm. This gives a ratio d15coarse/d85fine = 1·6. Considering increasing values of n, the largest diameter d15coarse complying with equation (3) is the coarsest particle of the stable PSD. All larger particles may be captured by the filter, but will not form voids small enough to retain the finer particles of the base soil. Continuing the example for material AP1, the maximum diameter of the stable PSD was found to be d15coarse = 0·055 mm, when n = 68% and d85fine = 0·011 mm. The reduced PSD, considering only the particles finer than the d15coarse diameter, defines the stable self-filtering fraction of the soil, shown in Fig. 2 for the AP1 material. The proposed technique suggests that a successful filter must be able to retain the self-filtering reduced PSD.The reduced PSD has been determined for each of the base soils tested, and for the data taken from the earlier work of Sherard (1984), Khor & Woo (1989) and Delgado (2000). Comparison with the critical filter diameter is shown for group 1 materials only in Fig. 4, along with the Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) design criterion D15F/d85 = 9. This criterion, when applied to the reduced PSD, seems overly conservative for most data. The line D15F/d85reduced = 12 forms a lower bound for the majority of the measured NEF boundaries. Sample AS1 plots below this design line; this material is a clay with a very uniform coarse fraction (d98B/d85B < 2). Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) also noted that uniform materials have a slightly lower D15bdy value, so this result is not unexpected. This analysis suggests that the reduced PSD method can be used to determine a safe filter for group 1 soils. All the materials tested were clays with PI > 10. Based on these observations, a new design criterion for group 1 soils, with PI > 10 and d98/d85 > 2, is proposed as (4)D15F≤12d85reducedThe NEF boundary filter diameter and d85 of the reduced PSD are plotted for the group 2 materials in Fig. 5. Comparison of Figs 1 and 5 indicates that the Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) filter criterion for group 2 materials, requiring D15F = 0·7 mm, is a lower bound for filter tests on all group 2 soils regardless of their ability to self-filter, and that significantly coarser filters are suitable for self-filtering base soils. The line D15F/d85reduced = 9 represents a conservative filter for the majority of the data. Notable exceptions are the materials S5, 81W895, BJV-C1 and BJV-C3. These four materials are sandy silts, having a low plasticity index, PI < 6, while the remaining group 2 materials are sandy clays and clayey sands with PI > 10. This suggests that the clay fraction causes particle aggregation, and produces larger particles that are stable during filtration. This aggregation of particles does not occur in low-plasticity materials such as sandy silts. These silty materials behave more like a non-cohesive base soil, and a filter retention ratio of D15F/d85B < 4 is probably more appropriate. Based on this analysis, a new design criterion is developed for group 2 materials. Broadly graded base soils may be unable to self-filter, because the coarse fraction of the material is often too coarse to act as a filter for the fine fraction. This means that filters designed by traditional filter design criteria (e.g. Sherard & Dunnigan, 1985) to retain the coarse fraction of the base soil may allow continued erosion of the fine fraction because self-filtration does not occur. A series of 15 no erosion filter tests, and published results of another 33 tests, were compared to examine filtration of broadly graded materials. One material was shown to have a critical filter diameter of D15F = 0·19 mm, while the Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) design criterion allowed D15F = 0·7 mm.A new technique, called the reduced PSD method, has been introduced to determine the self-filtering stable fraction of a broadly graded base soil. Examination of the laboratory data based on the reduced PSD showed that the following design criteria may be adopted. In comparison with the commonly used Sherard & Dunnigan (1985) criteria, these new design criteria often allow coarser filters for self-filtering base soils, while significantly finer filters may be necessary to protect some broadly graded materials.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Locke et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: