Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Distributive justice decisions are a fundamental aspect of social life. Which criteria (contribution, need, equality) do children and their parents use when deciding what they consider to be a fair distribution in situations where the criteria of contribution and need may conflict? And how can these decisions be explained? The present study examines three possible explanations for the development of distributive justice decisions between childhood and adolescence: (1) cognitive development, (2) value socialization by parents and (3) value socialization through different school environments. These questions were investigated longitudinally at two time points. German children participated the first time at age 10 (T1, n = 209) when they were in elementary school and a second time at age 12 (T2, n = 206) when they attended different tracks of secondary schools. Both children and their parents ( n = 109 at T1; n = 143 at T2) took part in an experiment in which they allocated resources 18 times between two recipients who systematically differed in effort and need. At age 10, children gave less resources to the diligent child as compared to age 12. Further, they either allocated the resources only according to the need of the recipient or considered both need and effort in their allocation decisions (integration). Two years later, at age 12, the number of children who integrated both criteria increased, supporting the hypothesis that moral development is driven by cognitive growth. At both T1 and T2, parents either gave more to the recipient who had invested more effort or integrated need and effort. The distributive justice decisions of parents and their children did not align in most parent–child pairs. The type of secondary school only influenced decisions in scenarios where one recipient was very needy. In these cases, students from the least academically oriented schools disregarded the level of effort exerted by the recipient. The results suggest that cognitive processes constitute the main developmental roots of distributive justice decisions between childhood and adolescence.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jutta Kienbaum (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: