Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Meta-analysis reveals the impact of straw return on soil organic carbon and maize yield in Northeast China, suggesting tailored practices based on local conditions.
As a vital grain production base in China, soil health and crop productivity in Northeast China are critical to national food security. Straw return is a key practice for improving soil fertility and crop yield, yet its effectiveness is subject to complex regulation by regional environmental and management factors. In this study, a meta-analysis was conducted to systematically evaluate the effects of straw return on soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks and maize yield in croplands of Northeast China, and to quantify the moderating roles of climatic conditions, soil properties, fertilization management, and straw return techniques. The results showed that straw return increased topsoil (0–20 cm) SOC stocks by an average of 10.1–18.1%. Among the evaluated categories, comparatively greater mean SOC responses were observed under low temperature (mean annual temperature <5 °C), low precipitation (annual precipitation of 300–400 mm), low initial SOC concentration (20–30 g kg−1), and Chernozems. For maize yield, comparatively high mean responses were observed under a mean annual temperature of 5–10 °C, annual precipitation of 600–700 mm, moderate initial SOC concentration, and brown soils. Regarding fertilization management, N application at 200–250 kg ha−1 was associated with a comparatively greater mean maize-yield response in the subgroup analysis, whereas SOC responses varied among N, P, and K application rates and fertilization methods. Therefore, the identified environmental and management ranges represent category-specific associations within the available dataset rather than causal or universally applicable optima. In terms of straw return practices, a duration of 5–10 years, incorporation of chopped straw, and full straw return were associated with relatively favorable responses among the evaluated categories. Structural equation modeling revealed that the direct path from SOC stock to maize yield was not significant (path coefficient = 0.07), being masked primarily by the fertilization effect (path coefficient = 0.67) and the carbon saturation mechanism (negative contribution of initial SOC, −0.83). This study uncovers a complex relationship between SOC stocks and crop yield. In practice, agricultural producers should select straw-return methods and amounts according to local climatic and soil conditions, consider chopped-straw incorporation under suitable local conditions, and coordinate straw inputs with soil-test-based, balanced N, P, and K fertilization and field monitoring rather than applying a single universal recommendation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: