Key result
Carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity devices show strong agreement with invasive aortic measures, unlike other noninvasive methods.
Why the study?
Aortic pulse wave velocity assesses aortic stiffness noninvasively by several methods, but whether commonly used noninvasive devices can all accurately estimate it remained to be determined.
Do noninvasive devices accurately estimate aortic pulse wave velocity compared to true invasive recordings in patients undergoing coronary angiography?
Observational (n=102)
Blinded assessment (operators blinded to opposite recordings)
Measurements sequentially performed in random order
No
Do noninvasive devices accurately estimate aortic pulse wave velocity compared to true invasive recordings in patients undergoing coronary angiography?
Carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity remains the most accurate noninvasive method to estimate true aortic stiffness, outperforming alternative device algorithms.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports preferring carotid-femoral PWV devices for aortic stiffness assessment; extends validation data but leaves outcome impact open.
Aortic pulse wave velocity is a worldwide accepted index to evaluate aortic stiffness and can be assessed noninvasively by several methods. This study sought to determine if commonly used noninvasive devices can all accurately estimate aortic pulse wave velocity. Pulse wave velocity was estimated in 102 patients (aged 65±13 years) undergoing diagnostic coronary angiography with 7 noninvasive devices and compared with invasive aortic pulse wave velocity. Devices evaluating carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity (Complior Analyse, PulsePen ET, PulsePen ETT, and SphygmoCor) showed a strong agreement between each other ( r >0.83) and with invasive aortic pulse wave velocity. The mean difference ±SD with the invasive pulse wave velocity was −0.73±2.83 m/s ( r =0.64) for Complior-Analyse: 0.20±2.54 m/s ( r =0.71) for PulsePen-ETT: −0.04±2.33 m/s ( r =0.78) for PulsePen ET; and −0.61±2.57 m/s ( r =0.70) for SphygmoCor. The finger-toe pulse wave velocity, evaluated by pOpmètre, showed only a weak relationship with invasive aortic recording (mean difference ±SD =−0.44±4.44 m/s; r =0.41), and with noninvasive carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity measurements ( r <0.33). Pulse wave velocity estimated through a proprietary algorithm by BPLab (v.5.03 and v.6.02) and Mobil-O-Graph showed a weaker agreement with invasive pulse wave velocity compared with carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity (mean difference ±SD =−0.71±3.55 m/s, r =0.23; 1.04±2.27 m/s, r =0.77; and −1.01±2.54 m/s, r =0.71, respectively), revealing a negative proportional bias at Bland-Altman plot. Aortic pulse wave velocity values provided by BPLab and Mobil-O-Graph were entirely dependent on age-squared and peripheral systolic blood pressure (cumulative r 2 =0.98 and 0.99, respectively). Thus, among the methods evaluated, only those assessing carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity (Complior Analyse, PulsePen ETT, PulsePen ET, and SphygmoCor) appear to be reliable approaches for estimation of aortic stiffness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Salvi et al. (2019) conducted an observational in Patients undergoing diagnostic coronary angiography (n=102). Noninvasive estimation of aortic pulse wave velocity (Complior Analyse, PulsePen ET, PulsePen ETT, SphygmoCor, pOpmètre, BPLab, Mobil-O-Graph) vs. Invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (intra-arterial catheter) was evaluated on Agreement between noninvasive devices and invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (Mean difference -0.73 to 0.20 m/s and r=0.64 to 0.78 for carotid-femoral devices). Noninvasive devices assessing carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity showed strong agreement with invasive aortic measurements, while other noninvasive approaches were unreliable.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: