Key result
Trial protocol evaluates Nadi Sodhana Pranayama versus chair aerobics for post-CABG anxiety and exercise tolerance.
Why the study?
Current Indian practice relies on western cardiac rehabilitation protocols that may not be suitable, and the comparative effects of pranayama and chair aerobics on post-CABG anxiety and exercise tolerance remain unclear.
Does Nadi Sodhana Chair aerobics combined with phase I cardiac rehabilitation improve anxiety and heart rate in CABG patients compared to chair aerobics alone?
RCT (n=100)
Single-blind (outcome assessor blinded)
Computer generated randomization with sequentially numbered, opaque, sealed envelopes (SNOSE)
No
Does Nadi Sodhana Chair aerobics combined with phase I cardiac rehabilitation improve anxiety and heart rate in CABG patients compared to chair aerobics alone?
This study protocol describes a randomized trial to evaluate the efficacy of Nadi Sodhana and chair aerobics on anxiety and exercise tolerance in patients undergoing CABG in India.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No results yet from this RCT protocol; leaves open whether Nadi Sodhana pranayama adds benefit over chair aerobics in post-CABG anxiety and tolerance.
Objectives: The current Indian scenario follows the western cardiac rehabilitation protocol; hence the primary aim of the study is to develop a cardiac rehabilitation phase 1 protocol for the Indian scenario. The protocol will be used in the study as standard rehabilitation protocol for the intervention groups. The literature suggests the use of Pranayama and chair aerobics to improve the anxiety in CABG patients. This study also aims to provide the answer for the effect of Pranayama and chair aerobics on anxiety and exercise tolerance in CABG patients. And also try to find out which among the two intervention is superior among one another. Methods: The cardiac rehabilitation protocol will be validated by experts in the field and applied in the patients and the results will be analysed. Then the protocol will be used as the standard rehabilitation protocol in both the groups. 100 patients will be randomised and allocated into 2 groups. Group 1 will receive Nadi Sodhana Chair aerobics for 15 minutes along with phase I cardiac rehabilitation. The group 2 will receive Chair aerobics for 15 minutes along with phase I cardiac rehabilitation. The outcome measures will be taken before the surgery and on the post-operative day 7. The primary outcome measures are Hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS) and Heart rate and the secondary outcome measure is 6-minute walk test. The intention to treat analysis will be done after the data collection. Results: The data will be analysed using unpaired t test, p value <0.05 will be considered significant. Conclusion: The result will give a new insight into the field of cardiac surgery, where the effect of pranayama and chair aerobics on anxiety and functional outcome will be proved. CTRI registration: This trial is prospectively registered in CTRI, the registration number of the trial is CTRI/2021/09/037008 . Highlights: What is already known about this subject? The effect of Pranayama and chair aerobics on various components like pain, peak expiratory flow after CABG is proven in different studies. The phase 1 cardiac rehabilitation is practiced and adopted from western protocol. What does this study add? The study will give a new insight into the field of cardiac rehabilitation. Definite phase I cardiac rehabilitation protocol for Indian population is not exist in the literature. The Indian set up is using the western protocol, which is not suitable for the Indian population hence could not achieve the expected outcome on discharge. We believe that this study will provide a definite phase I cardiac rehabilitation protocol for the Indian population. This can be followed in the community. Also, this study aims to explore the unexplored area of anxiety after CABG. Where the effect of the Pranayama and chair aerobics will be identified. And also give idea about which treatment technique is superior, and feasible for the patients. How might this impact on clinical practice? The study will provide a new phase I cardiac rehabilitation protocol for the Indian population. The protocol can be practiced in the Indian scenario. This will help to improve the exercise tolerance of the patients after the surgery. The study will recommend the feasible and effective technique for relieving the anxiety and improving the exercise tolerance in CABG patients. This can be implemented as a best practice in reducing anxiety after CABG.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ashok et al. (2021) conducted an RCT in Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting (CABG) with anxiety (n=100). Nadi Sodhana Pranayama (Yoga therapy) and Phase I cardiac rehabilitation vs. Chair aerobics for 15 minutes and Phase I cardiac rehabilitation was evaluated on Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) and Heart Rate. As this is a study protocol for a randomized clinical trial, no results are yet available regarding the effect of Nadi Sodhana Pranayama versus chair aerobics on anxiety and exercise tolerance.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: