Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
People have a variety of reasons for their interest in the extent of children's logical ability. Mine has developed from an interest in the teaching of critical thinking. I have earlier argued (Ennis, 1962) that deductive logic plays an essential role in all aspects of critical thinking. This is not to claim that deductive logic is in itself sufficient to deal properly with the range of decisions and choices we must make, rather that it is a necessary tool. If this is so, then both the efforts to teach critical thinking to students and the expectations of previous critical thinking attainment by students assume a degree of facility in deductive logic on the part of the students. If such facility is absent, then the efforts will fail and the expectations will be wrong; thus, postponement or abandonment, or some successful teaching of the required logical facility will be necessary. To be more specific: If a person is attempting to show students that the occurrence of several successful predicted instances does not by itself prove a generalization, that person should be interested in whether the students know that a proposition does not imply its converse (though the students need not put the knowledge in that language); a person who wants to show students the import of the failure of a prediction from a hypothesis
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert H. Ennis (1975) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: