Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: I read with interest the recently published manuscript by Magown et al1 as well as commentary provided by Reveulta-Gutierrez et al2 and subsequent response by Magown et al.3 Importantly, there are a number of assertions proposed in the Magown et al1 manuscript and response,3 which I will address. I will restrict my comments to 2 areas of interest: trigeminal neuralgia (TN) classification and Dr Peter Jannetta's purported intentional use of rhizolysis at the conclusion of microvascular decompression (MVD). The reader should understand that “TN1 and 2” are part of a statistical construct originally designed to avoid “the danger that patients with otherwise treatable facial pain will be discarded on the heap of the atypical.”4 In the Magown et al1 manuscript, however, the authors reference “trigeminal neuralgia type 1 (TN1) or classical trigeminal neuralgia” as if they are one in the same. They are not.5 For example, although patients with long-standing classical TN may develop a lower level, near constant background pain over time, that background pain is always eclipsed by triggered pain paroxysms of brief duration. Patients with classical TN do not experience facial pain (ie, “in a paroxysmal, severe, electrical, and triggerable pattern”) merely half of the time or less. Classical TN is a unique clinical entity and follows Justice Stewart's “I know it when I see it” observation. And to confuse the matter even more, recent criteria put forward by a consensus panel, including members from the International Association for the study of Pain and the European Academy of Neurology, suggest that a diagnosis of classical TN can only be made with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) evidence of neurovascular compression with morphologic changes of the trigeminal nerve root.6 We know that this is not so because a minority of patients meeting all other criteria of classical TN do not have vascular compression of their trigeminal nerves and therefore cannot possibly benefit from MVD.8 In the response to Magown et al2 the authors finally suggest that “Jannetta made it a point to judiciously traumatize the nerve at the conclusion of MVD.” This statement is factually incorrect and undermines the contribution that Jannetta made to the pathogenesis and potential treatment of TN. The allegation that Jannetta advocated or employed “traumatization” of the nerve during MVD cannot be substantiated by either the authors of these reports or by the many surgeons who actually operated with or were trained by Jannetta. Therefore, the reader is left to believe that important information, such as durability of relief with MVD for typical (ie, the term “classical” was not used in 1996) TN, as provided by Barker et al,9 cannot be trusted because MVD, as described in that report, was accompanied by some form of nerve injury or frank rhizolysis of the nerve to assure “immediate and durable” pain relief. A real limitation of the study by Barker et al9 however, is that those authors did not have the benefit of utilizing high-resolution MRI which has transformed our understanding of the appropriateness of MVD as the best option for classical TN. Increasingly, we are beginning to better understand the relative contributions of severity of neurovascular compression (NVC), as also suggested by Magown et al and by a recent publication from our group.7 When counseling patients regarding durability of relief with MVD, I now rely on recent data from our group with a median follow-up of 41 mo, which complements the work of Barker et al9 and others and incorporates high-resolution MRI as well as type of TN and response to ox/carbamazepine.10 None of my comments are to suggest that we really understand the pathophysiology of NVC in TN. We do not, but it is important to clarify what we do indeed know. Disclosures The author has no personal, financial, or institutional interest in any of the drugs, materials, or devices described in this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Raymond F. Sekula (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: