Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Evaluates the impact of BAC limits on road safety in Brazil, suggesting a need for data collection reforms.
It has been nearly two decades since Brazil implemented its first drinking and driving law, when driving with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) above 0.06% was considered a ‘driving under the influence’ (DUI) offence 1. Since the law's inception the legislation has undergone numerous modifications, including the reduction of the BAC limit to the current zero tolerance law: a blood alcohol level above 0.01% is deemed an administrative offense with a fine and short licence suspension, while a criminal offence with a higher fine, criminal record and possible jail time, occurs when a driver has a BAC above 0.06% 2. Studies conducted during this period have supported that both establishing a BAC limit for drivers, as well as lowering it, had a positive effect on road traffic injuries and the proportion of DUI reports 3-5. However, fundamental data such as BACs from injured drivers are still not collected systematically at the national level 6, leaving a large gap where strategies are being implemented without rigorous evaluation of their effectiveness 7. Denying a breath test during a DUI investigation under law 12 760/2012 2 is penalized only by an administrative penalty (fine and temporary driver's licence suspension), while criminal sanctions that include jail time and harsher administrative sanctions for drunk drivers are usually applied only if someone is detected with a BAC of 0.06% or higher. In other words, refusing a breath test under a DUI investigation will result in a modest fine (around US$ 500), but these penalties are minimal compared to undergoing a criminal prosecution that might result in imprisonment. Practitioners in the road safety field are frustrated by these legislative loopholes. Brazilian researchers are also pessimistic about finding an immediate solution to impaired driving. Without basic data on levels of impaired driving being made available, Brazil has become a true ‘social experiment’ in terms of understanding the deterrence effects expected from enforcing DUI laws in developing regions. Recent data collected from drivers stopped at random DUI checkpoints in the biggest city in Brazil might highlight further the nature of this public health issue that currently ranks among the deadliest in low- to middle-income countries. Between July and August 2015, we observed 1057 drivers who were stopped by routine random DUI checkpoints in six different locations in São Paulo from Friday to Sunday following an international standard data collection procedure 8, 9. We collected information on drivers who were stopped randomly and submitted to alcohol breath tests. Of all drivers, 14.1% screened positive for any alcohol, which was a higher prevalence than results from previous studies in Brazil 10. Among these alcohol-positive drivers, almost 60% refused additional testing to determine their BAC. Many developed countries have halved their road traffic deaths involving alcohol by increasing the chance of offenders being caught by police while driving under the influence 11. Brazil has joined the fight to reduce the overwhelming number of almost 40 000 road traffic deaths a year; however, the effectiveness of these strategies needs to be measured. This work was supported by a grant provided by Bloomberg Philanthropies as part of the Bloomberg Initiative for Global Road Safety. G.A. is currently supported by São Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP) and CAPES Foundation from Brazil (#2014/01054-0). All other authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. All the opinions, conclusions and recommendations expressed in this material are the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the point of view from FAPESP and CAPES.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andreuccetti et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: