Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Compares eDNA and traditional sampling for assessing aquatic biodiversity in tropical freshwater ecosystems, suggesting tailored approaches are needed.
Freshwater ecosystems are under pressure from several anthropogenic stressors, resulting in a decline in freshwater biodiversity worldwide. Therefore, it is necessary to quantitatively and efficiently determine the species composition of communities in order to conserve biodiversity. Yet, large-scale biodiversity surveys, whether spanning a country or an entire continent, often face tight time constraints that make exhaustive assessments unfeasible. Still, they urgently require sampling methods that are not only quantitative, repeatable, and consistent, but also practical, in order to generate meaningful biodiversity indices across anthropogenic, altitudinal, or geographical gradients. Two common sampling methods are traditional physical sampling approaches and eDNA. In aquatic environments, traditional sampling is usually incomplete, time-consuming, and invasive, while eDNA can provide a more complete picture of communities in a non-invasive way. Few studies have compared traditional and eDNA biodiversity assessments for fish and invertebrate species, especially in tropical regions and in the context of large-scale, short-term biodiversity surveys. Our aim was to determine if eDNA could replace traditional taxonomic sampling for assessing aquatic biodiversity across small tropical freshwater systems of French Guiana. We found that for fishes, eDNA identified 62 taxa, while 13 taxa were found by traditional sampling (with 7 taxa in common to both methods), while for invertebrates the 16 taxa found by eDNA were all also found by traditional sampling, where 70 taxa were identified. The most common fish species identified by eDNA were Hoplias malabaricus (16/18 sites) and Krobia aff. guianensis (15/18 sites) and the most common invertebrate family from traditional sampling was Libellulidae (14/18 sites). Our findings likely reflect fundamental biological differences in DNA shedding rates between taxa: fishes, as vertebrates, release more DNA into the environment through mucus, scales, and excretion, while invertebrates, with their chitinous cuticle, shed far less. In such contexts, invertebrate diversity is better characterized through traditional taxonomic methods, whereas fish biodiversity is more effectively assessed using eDNA approaches. These results, though obtained in French Guiana, have broader implications for large-scale, short-term biodiversity surveys, and highlight the need to tailor eDNA strategies to taxa-specific shedding patterns.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elliott et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: