Patients with serious cardiac disease had a significantly higher rate of transitory cardiac complications during ECT compared to matched controls, but 38 of 40 completed the treatment course.
Cohort (n=80)
Does electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) cause an unsafe rate of cardiovascular complications in depressed patients with serious cardiac disease compared to those without cardiac disease?
Electroconvulsive therapy can be safely administered to depressed patients with severe cardiovascular disease with close monitoring, as cardiac complications are mostly transitory and rarely prevent treatment completion.
OBJECTIVE: This study was conducted to determine the safety of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) for depressed patients with serious cardiac disease. METHOD: The rate of complications in 40 patients with major depressive disorder and left ventricular impairment, ventricular arrhythmias, and/or conduction delay who received ECT was compared to the rate of complications in a matched comparison group of 40 depressed patients without cardiac disease who also received ECT. In addition, 21 of the patients with cardiac illness had received one or more inpatient trials of tricyclic antidepressants before receiving ECT, thereby permitting a comparison of cardiovascular complications of medication and ECT in the same patients. RESULTS: The patients with cardiac disease had a significantly higher rate of cardiac complications during ECT than did the comparison group without cardiac disease. The type of preexisting cardiac abnormality strongly predicted the type of cardiac complication that occurred during ECT. However, most of the complications were transitory and did not prevent the completion of ECT. Of the 21 patients with cardiac disease who had received tricyclic trials before ECT, 11 had been forced to discontinue drug treatment because of substantial cardiovascular side effects. In comparison, 38 of the 40 cardiac patients completed the course of ECT. CONCLUSIONS: With close monitoring for the development of arrhythmia and ischemic episodes, ECT can be given with relative safety to patients with severe cardiovascular disease.
ZIELINSKI et al. (Tue,) conducted a cohort in Major depressive disorder with serious cardiac disease (n=80). Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) vs. ECT in patients without cardiac disease was evaluated on Rate of cardiac complications during ECT. Patients with serious cardiac disease had a significantly higher rate of transitory cardiac complications during ECT compared to matched controls, but 38 of 40 completed the treatment course.