Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
During my second year of medical school, I learned that migraines with aura are a contraindication to combined oral contraceptives, which I had been taking for years. I casually asked my doctor during my next appointment whether this applied to me. I suspected I was being paranoid, learning all these new disease processes in class and excessively applying them to myself. To my surprise, though, she immediately said I was not allowed to take my pills anymore. She looked alarmed. I grew alarmed. I was unsuccessful in convincing either of us that my tongue numbness was not an aura. My doctor said: “We’ll figure out a plan. But you can’t take any more of your pills. Okay?” We were well over time, my denial was waning, and the plan seemed pretty straightforward: Stop taking my pills. I felt and said: “Okay.” Later that day, I realized that we hadn’t addressed the risk of pregnancy coming off the Pill. The office was closed, so I sent my doctor a message explaining my worries and asking if I should take my next pill. In the meanwhile, I contacted Planned Parenthood’s chat line. They said: “We cannot advise you to take the Pill if your doctor said not to. You need to contact her. You can take Plan B if you’re really concerned.” The clinic’s nurse practitioner repeated this refrain on the phone the next day: “Your risk of pregnancy is low, but you can take Plan B if you’re really concerned.” I sent my doctor a follow-up message, explaining my hesitations to take Plan B as recommended and asking whether I could just take my pills for another week instead. Then I waited. One of my biggest fears about becoming a doctor is knowing I will inevitably fall short of the expectations my patients will and deserve to have of me. I am only human. Every doctor is only human. I want to believe that if I am understanding of my imperfect experiences as a patient, then my future patients might also be understanding of me as their imperfect doctor. So although I was worried about this time-sensitive concern, I reminded myself it was not reasonable to expect my doctor to answer immediately. I decided to take my pills temporarily and develop a more informed, concrete decision once I received my doctor’s input. Three days later, my relief in receiving her response quickly turned to disappointment when I read her reply: “Chances of pregnancy are low, but you can take Plan B if you’re really concerned.” It was the same answer, nearly word-for-word that I’d already received from Planned Parenthood … and nothing else. I easily could have (and had) found such a generic answer on the Internet. I had sought out “my doctor” because she could provide what Dr. Google could not—the personalization and compassion of patient-centered care and the confidence gained from shared decision making. In medical school, we are taught that it is essential to listen to and consider a patient’s values, goals, and life realities in our decision making. Ideally, this should be a two-way dialogue, a shared process that results in a decision that benefits that individual patient. In reaching out to my doctor, I was hoping for information that would either reassure me that Plan B as the standing recommendation was indeed the best option for me and my specific circumstances or help me more confidently pursue a different plan. I found neither. I felt the disappointment of having my concerns left unaddressed, and the recommendation to take Plan B without further explanation did not feel like and ultimately was not a decision we shared. I made my own decision, no more informed than I was before receiving a reply, to continue taking my pills against medical advice. As a medical student, I had read about and discussed the difference that patient-centered care and shared decision making can have in ensuring patient satisfaction and outcomes. My experience as a patient was a small but personal example that drove home those communication lessons in a lasting way. I’ve been studying to “program” my brain with medical knowledge. Yet, Dr. Google can unquestionably hold more content and provide it more rapidly, widely, and reliably than I ever will. While patients can connect to the Internet for answers more conveniently, a physician’s ability to partner with patients and listen, care for, and apply that knowledge within the context of an individual’s life exemplifies the healing power of human connection. Instead of perceiving my humanity as a reason why I may fall short of my patients’ needs and expectations, I now understand that it is also a way I can meet them. Acknowledgment: The author would like to warmly thank Dr. Andrew Barnosky and Dr. Trisha Paul for their constant encouragement and role modeling of both the healing power of human connection and writing in medicine. Hsin (Cindy) Lee, MDH. Lee is a first-year resident, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan; e-mail: [email protected]; Twitter: @hsincindylee.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hsin Lee (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: