Key result
The Geriatric Depression Scale administered by telephone showed substantial concordance with face-to-face administration and clinical diagnosis.
Why the study?
Is the Geriatric Depression Scale reliable and valid when administered by telephone compared to face-to-face assessment in geriatric patients?
Observational (n=101)
Single-blind
No
Is the Geriatric Depression Scale reliable and valid when administered by telephone compared to face-to-face assessment in geriatric patients?
The Geriatric Depression Scale maintains its reliability and validity when administered by telephone, supporting its use for epidemiological and clinical purposes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Telephone GDS may support remote geriatric screening; leaves open prospective validation in broader populations.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate prospectively the reliability and validity of the Geriatric Depression Scale administered by telephone (T-GDS) in patients undergoing outpatient comprehensive geriatric assessment. SUBJECTS: A total of 101 geriatric patients were evaluated in a 1-year period at the outpatient Geriatric Assessment Center of the University of Nebraska Medical Center. METHODS: The 30-item GDS was completed by all patients on three occasions: by telephone several days before their assessment, face-to-face during their assessment visit, and several days later, again by phone. During their assessment, all patients were evaluated by one of three geriatric psychiatrists who were blind to all GDS results. The test-retest reliability of the T-GDS was measured by comparing the results of the two phone interviews. The construct validity of the T-GDS was estimated by comparing the results of the initial T-GDS to the GDS obtained during the comprehensive assessment. The criterion validity of the T-GDS was estimated by comparing the results of the T-GDS with the clinical diagnosis of depression assigned by the psychiatrists. RESULTS: The individual items of the initial T-GDS showed substantial concordance with the second T-GDS (kappa range 0.35-0.75, mean = 0.52), and with the assessment GDS (kappa range 0.29-0.75, mean = 0.52). One item showed evidence of bias when comparing the two T-GDSs, and two items when comparing the initial T-GDS to the GDS done during the assessment. The mean number of symptomatic responses was not significantly different for the T-GDS versus assessment administration but did decline slightly when comparing the two T-GDSs. ROC curve analyses showed good agreement between the clinical diagnosis and the T-GDS. CONCLUSION: The GDS appears to maintain its reliability and validity when administered via telephone and thus may be useful for a variety of epidemiological and clinical purposes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Burke et al. (1995) conducted an observational in Depression (n=101). Geriatric Depression Scale administered by telephone (T-GDS) vs. Face-to-face GDS and clinical diagnosis was evaluated on Concordance of initial T-GDS with second T-GDS and assessment GDS (mean kappa 0.52). The Geriatric Depression Scale administered by telephone showed substantial concordance with face-to-face administration and clinical diagnosis.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: